The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About6666-6666.Overtime.15-12-21 DecisionCrown Employees Grievance Settlement Board Suite 600 180 Dundas St. West Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8 Tel. (416) 326-1388 Fax (416) 326-1396 Commission de règlement des griefs des employés de la Couronne Bureau 600 180, rue Dundas Ouest Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8 Tél. : (416) 326-1388 Téléc. : (416) 326-1396 GSB#6666-6666 IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION Under THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT Before THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD BETWEEN Ontario Public Service Employees Union (Union) Union - and - The Crown in Right of Ontario (Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services) Employer BEFORE Felicity D. Briggs Vice-Chair FOR THE UNION Nick Mustari Ontario Public Service Employees Union Grievance Officer FOR THE EMPLOYER Greg Gledhill Treasury Board Secretariat Centre for Employee Relations Employee Relations Advisor HEARING CONFERENCE CALL September 24, October 20 & 28, 2015 December 4, 2015 - 2 - Decision [1] In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was decided that overtime grievances should be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely manner to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each institution. Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped that these monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances. [2] It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to deal only with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would meet to attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining disputes would be put before this Board. [3] In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. There have been further sessions and decisions issued. The process has not been altered. [4] The parties met on September 24, 2015, October 20, 2015 and October 28, 2015. We also held a conference call on December 4, 2015. Overtime grievances were heard from Central East Correctional Centre, Monteith Correctional Complex, Kenora Jail, TIC, and North Bay Jail. Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and submissions regarding the various disputes. Attached is the list of grievances and the disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors as set out in the attached are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate less statutory deductions. - 3 - [5] I remain seized. Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 21st day of December 2015. Felicity D. Briggs, Vice Chair - 4 - Grievor Name GSB Number OPSEU File Number Result Belanger, Armand 2014-4179 2014-0369-0159 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Biemann, Lisette 2014-0155 2014-0642-0012 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Bourgeois, Lawrence 2010-0546 2010-0642-0025 Dismissed Brownlee, Sarah 2014-4103 2014-0616-0040 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Burke, Sharon 2013-0363 2013-0642-0014 Dismissed Chrysler, Chris 2014-4180 2014-0369-0160 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Daoust, Roger 2014-4752 2014-0616-0045 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Delaurier, Edward 2012-1752 2012-0642-0034 Dismissed Denault, Wendy 2014-3201 2014-0642-0033 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-2863 2013-0369-0048 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Dionne, Richard 2013-2864 2013-0369-0049 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Dionne, Richard 2013-2865 2013-0369-0050 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Dionne, Richard 2013-2866 2013-0369-0051 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Dionne, Richard 2013-3548 2013-0369-0070 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-3549 2013-0369-0071 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-3550 2013-0369-0072 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-3551 2013-0369-0073 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-3552 2013-0369-0074 Dismissed Dionne, Richard 2013-3646 2013-0369-0081 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Dobson, Halcea 2015-0878 2015-0719-0016 Dismissed Faulds, Robert 2014-4071 2014-0719-0013 Dismissed Fletcher, John 2013-2874 2013-0369-0059 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Giles, Jenifer 2013-2832 2013-0369-0047 Dismissed Girard, David 2015-0726 2015-0642-0009 Dismissed Girard, David 2012-3856 2012-0642-0054 Dismissed Girard, David 2014-0321 2014-0642-0013 Dismissed Girard, David 2014-4194 2014-0642-0040 Dismissed Girard, David 2015-0810 2015-0642-0012 Dismissed Girard, David 2015-0844 2015-0642-0016 Dismissed Guillemette, Joey 2012-1533 2012-0642-0023 Allowed – 4 x 2 Hours Hervieux, Sherry 2014-2154 2014-0369-0146 Dismissed Hill, Tracy 2014-2885 2014-0616-0020 Dismissed Humphrey, David 2015-0997 2015-0616-0011 Dismissed Hurjui, Aurora 2014-4178 2014-0369-0158 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Hurjui, Olivian 2014-4183 2014-0369-0163 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Hylands, Richard 2010-2993 2010-0521-0122 Dismissed Imbeau, Todd 2013-2059 2013-0642-0026 Dismissed Imbeau, Todd 2014-0630 2014-0642-0017 Dismissed Knight, Carol 2014-0535 2014-0616-0011 Upheld In Part - 3.5 Hours OT Macpherson, Sadie 2013-0543 2013-0521-0031 Dismissed McCutcheon, Victor 2013-2867 2013-0369-0052 Dismissed McCutcheon, Victor 2013-2868 2013-0369-0053 Dismissed McCutcheon, Victor 2013-2869 2013-0369-0054 Allowed – 11 Hours OT - 5 - Grievor Name GSB Number OPSEU File Number Result McCutcheon, Victor 2013-2870 2013-0369-0055 Dismissed McCutcheon, Victor 2013-2871 2013-0369-0056 Dismissed Melvin,Thomas 2013-2873 2013-0369-0058 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Melvin,Thomas 2013-3649 2013-0369-0080 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Melvin,Thomas 2013-3653 2014-0369-0003 Dismissed Melvin,Thomas 2014-1142 2014-0369-0136 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Morgan, Stewart J. 2015-0876 2015-0719-0014 Dismissed Mortley, Jeremy 2013-2910 2013-0369-0060 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Nowe, James 2014-4529 2015-0719-0002 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Nowe, James 2014-4530 2015-0719-0003 Dismissed Nowe, James 2014-4515 2014-0719-0015 Dismissed O'Reilly, Santa 2010-2280 2010-0521-0100 Dismissed O'Toole, Ronald E. 2011-2299 2011-0521-0029 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Pearson, Brian 2013-3680 2013-0369-0083 Dismissed Peever, Dave 2012-0974 2012-0642-0014 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Purificati, David 2013-3769 2014-0642-0003 Dismissed Purificati, David 2014-2332 2014-0642-0026 Allowed – 4 Hours OT Robert, Philippe 2010-0549 2010-0642-0026 Allowed – 4.5 Hours OT Robert, Philippe 2010-1239 2010-0642-0031 Dismissed Saucier, Amanda 2014-2796 2014-0616-0017 Dismissed Stauton, Adam 2013-3647 2013-0369-0082 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Steinbrunner, Kenneth 2015-0812 2015-0642-0014 Dismissed Sutherland, Steve 2013-3309 2013-0616-0043 Allowed – 8 Hours OT Sutherland, Steve 2013-3310 2013-0616-0044 Dismissed Sutherland, Steve 2013-4301 2014-0616-0003 Dismissed Sutherland, Steve 2014-3290 2014-0616-0025 Dismissed Verreault, Jason 2014-2750 2014-0369-0148 Dismissed Vigfusson, Sturn 2015-0877 2015-0719-0015 Dismissed Vigfusson, Sturn 2015-0874 2015-0719-0012 Dismissed Wherley, John 2014-4065 2014-0369-0168 Dismissed Whiltshire, Adam 2014-1144 2014-0369-0138 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Whiltshire, Adam 2014-1145 2014-0369-0139 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Whiltshire, Adam 2014-1146 2014-0369-0140 Dismissed Whiltshire, Adam 2014-1147 2014-0369-0141 Dismissed Whiltshire, Adam 2014-1148 2014-0369-0142 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Whiltshire, Adam 2014-4181 2014-0369-0161 Allowed – 12 Hours OT Whiting, Edward 2009-1492 2009-0642-0007 Dismissed Whiting, Edward 2012-0665 2012-0642-0012 Dismissed Zieminski, Daniel 2014-4341 2014-0642-0009 Allowed – 12 Hours OT