HomeMy WebLinkAbout1994-2412CARRUTHERS96_01_05
ONTARIO EMPLOYES DE LA COURONNE
'" CROWN EMPLOYEES DE L 'ONTARIO
11111 GRIEVANCE COMMISSION DE
SETTLEMENT REGLEMENT
BOARD DES GRIEFS
180 DUNDAS STREET WEST, SUITE 2100, TORONTO ON M5G 1Z8 TELEPHONEITEUiPHONE (416) 326-1388
180, RUE DUNDAS OUEST, BUREAU 2100, TORONTO (ON) M5G 1Z8 FACSIMILElTELECOPIE (416) 326-1396
GSB# 2412/94, 2413/94, 2414/94
OPSEU# 95C263, 95C264, 95C265
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
OPSEU (Carruthers)
Grievor
- and -
The Crown in Right of ontario
(Hinlstry of Health)
Employer
BEFORE N Backhouse Vice-Chairperson
FOR_THE N Roland
G Bl:~ V01~ Barrister & Solicitor
FQR TH~ ,.< Nixon
l:
~NPLOYE~ Counsel
Legal Services Branch
Manaqement Board Secretariat
HE~RI!!g December 13, 1995
Januar1 4 5, 1996
,
;
GSB# 2412/94, 2413/94, 2414/94
OPSEU# 95C263, 95C264, 95C265
BOARD ORDER
Attached is the Memorandum of Settlement which the parties
agreed would be made an Order of the Board
DATED at Toronto, this 5th day of January, 1996
~c:45~
N Back.house, \ice-Chalrperson
.
!\'1{~~1\ di,/1(.\,,\ /,) I,lllllhlhl
! i\ \ I, (~ t \
-Il ,,-I \ l \ I l " 't I I \ I [~I (( ,.)) J
I~ I \ L~ r'-. \, II '"I (r )
(C ~ ,{{
- i~
I-I ~~\ l,"JC..--'l \ 0\J1l(\.., ('-'-t ~ '"-, l~,v \.Jh'(j('-. Lit l \..
L llu.. LU,\l' )
j~ I J:{
,.
--~ I', (''-
ItA \ \ ~L\!ICll\.i.'
)
cl1u (~iltl:\)
'}! ;l-
I , ^ '
L~\ l'\'v 1~1't\t L\ dv. {jfll\-(I~ 'v\.,)_((d~lr~ iJ/ILl C it,,1
J ( I ( I ,...~ t i';'4 ! i ~ . ~ ,," ~
, , l i ' " I '- --t, ~~--;I L ~ , {\ i, ,I r rk I '1 "I' (i, t
'\. ,
, ( \ ,'( I ~. I .r C' ' . '\ {' ~ I
\l_~ J\ ,v\~\ i\~\ ,,'tl ~\Lll(U "1. C~- \k-: '1 \ l/!l,!~,
. ,/
I , \ .
G \ ... I ! 1.1/ l i L \, L t {I I )", ( c de ~ t i! (I.. t ~ I' l t -, )'( i L ~", )
\, ' (
I Ill.' I'II!'\,,\ it'd jL~){ It! (~L(( I'l~((-I ~(1fl'I}LL/-
I
-
t ( ) -rk ( :4'Yl L ,l q)/ r )( f r.l \ -( ( -, I I ( (I I lell! ( Ie ' Lf I t L l~ I
I , I
/ I { }~
d, tt::::o /F- )L / ) r) \ L( ) /)/)/) )
,'- (0
/;) -7-' "- i, ,)_ ( L r 1 L-<: l/~ j l. ( )u
" y C (I ~ / /' '- ./ l' , - I ( ( II / .J -f' 01 ' ' L
\~
I
\. )..- ~- ~ ( i <- I / . - f , J '. j / ) l II . - ( )...l
~ I '- -l -~ ( I ,
~/ I
'\
t 1\ ! l' I C LIl '- O( C / L c?J ..L -7 I A~ ~/L / t C)) ) )-L-; l 1--.(
/-
IJt'lll\(l ~ / ( . Ie ( -(~7 ,1
C'J )/ I- I c/ {/ \,- f U l/ I L
A tf I {((f lj
I
/'''''
1;1 -r: (It n Ifl- c )(~ '--)l~ I-/t. I ) (. Il~! -~ ( ) /-
) ) ( I i Ii . 1
'~- :;; I j ~ l (Lt' C-t c.__,( ,.)
I; . 1 \ Lie
I, I _ CJ,_ IlL' L[!))CL-C)~j I \ f
, >-!' ~ -~)
I I. - .0-1-'
IJC- (J v
~c l)/~ "1
- J\
A ---j- II IJ - ff', l );}c..../ /)l L L I
I ( ! (,
f "';1 / ~._...-\: c:r~ ( L, I -{ .{:- I Y- (' ( C / '^,(./ {.
I I
'v d
-ll ,"'c ( L ~ (\_l t( f J (
--
, I L I ( , - '_ I j j t ~ I -, L ~ IJ ( / /' f.( l J~ ;-.
'--, l_ I I ,. l \ /", /
\.....- l I
/
l)lL. { (, ' J ' IL' !)\ /11j j I ' L( ) / (Ii, (lf2.j <~. /__ I l /1; <-.1-, I)) (- / l ! j )
\_ L
II (ll.{( 1({"Jr/; ji" ~IL L I '>
,\~ I ( - I / II II !//t(l/U ,/'l/l):t"r1 if' (/ II/! 'i1,1. ( i'fJ 2. "
v (I,
L f L , ..t ' -..x;-...-4'... ~ ~ t ~--==
;
.
0) nu -, (LJit, I _ y c{ I ( 1(.( i " \. I ) (
~J' ( ( l I !/(' (' ( I" I ~ I ( I ( l )1
"-
c~ I ( /, I r I Ie 6 /i ( ') j ) ill )l I /-/(~ )l ! ( I I I( ( {
( { l { ( l' (! ('{ I {,( / ( l \ ') /1 /1 ' 'e 1
L I C ( '-, / I L '/ ( I)' (
( I I){ ( ! (:. L l /1
) (\ I, ') " L ·
I 1_
/ f/
(]J .--..---- - j-c I -k j-,c , 1./ li-, y('~ /'i( I
I ! CJ.~ / - (L{) ,{,,-, -J
l .J I (: <-- L
/
'./ ~
.
/'/( { ~ /1,1<''-( j J I l I L I., ------r;- -II; ,)j
, / - IIUe
I ft'
J-c L <.. (*-..1; J ) )1. ( );( _)( / '---' {{ ..(.J ( (/ / ~ /c
I (~( l t ( L ,(J :,1'[ [1.- (,
..--;:-
Ic' r:.. r 'ff L-{
/Z ( L ')( ~(Ct (. 1'0- I ('ta j tf" ~ :ff l-t-/I,L-I-iJ.....t.{" of
/
(
/-. / I I/,! C ,- //; ~ J 1(.1 I ( ( rJ IlL ,/ I (/
( ~ I
" / ~; r i I
1
[ J 0-(. I' /' Y .L / ' ,-, /1. (, / I Ie L I {tl _ I"t c d,1 J
l- _ '( t _.:- [,L L '- (( I r I' I
L -- ~ ; I -
I I
, ,
,.l1..<.1.ll/_ r\ /~ ~I _.----\.
(' ...--- , 1 t ~ / . /'
( \', ' / J[.l:r L i (, l l /-Lj I t \, -11-// Ii 1';(1/'11-/\ -< -----" (
I b l l -t-'
~ C ~ --
L.
! ~ ~,.
-, /)..' -, /~ '-1 '......\. '""'-.L r '- ',,--- /~--- ..-----......., .- '........ ------------------
,_/ ;- r "1-,,~ I ~_ ~ L -0 ........ ..........---
-,,-
hr--1 I u,( I id_ ~ h i ( fJ d) ( L J l( I Ill. ,,- lA'j tL-';tpt+ C Ct (I -:;. ( S
...}- (I) i 1'/-/(11 ~tlll,ICLUf, Iz.JII)I,/U/'., J"deUClCfO Fol(!,/Jd_I d'jl Itf}(:"
I 0\..\ \O~J I~O 10, '1 I'l, '-l- Iv..} ~1-0 --I<.. bA. LvW~O t/
, I . / 1/., ( / r( ~ I fA- I 7 I j'
\" ) LI (LC (, L IL J (U d '- L!U.;r f (. I L' lo' J, i, " I I, ( ,,' J. ".,/\.-A ci "-) I It'll. IJ I I
[ - .... \ d.l "c/ L- ( ()." {; j
l ~" ~ l If "-
......- -
I i \'ll. ! It 'I 1- l f I 1 (^~, I J
(I i till) i ~( It ( (lir(ct/i/~1 1 '1/ L /" () ( ,1 ' , d, tl ill, I.)'~ i H 'l'j OJ) 1 (heft ;-, i. II I
I ) tf~f~ { ,j ('it ((t ,,( 1 l / I I / I II\' Ii /, jl)- \-,/,1 "/ 1 /< , )
I
( i II
I ~A '~~~~_~~~~ ';,qb'>-c~~ .lc-':i:idt
_/. "--. -r - .. ~ -'.- ...J../ ~
- Ie I. / i{ / J
( (( '-T . C/ , II. l (- I ) J ,i ! j II I (--:(I~I -Z( / ) LC l 1 ( i (
! t l (
(
/1///'( ,..\ ('CV hL2L/r//{(
(' , elL'/) (.! (i {',; (, fI (, ~11 "J C,j J i I
I l \,. l 1 .Y, .. L/ I( c
) .
/1 / ~ , L L U Zt/ j t t "p J 1 '/) 1 I r J -, /1 (j1l,~, 1.1,0;" (I t", I ( \~ ({ t I v )
. -",'.i__ ! I I ll....A..." l l L. II')"' f Ii, IcL, L. J'- 1.1/ ,CV-<
I ., ~1 ' ') r r;. "I I'! l J ( I l' ! [( iL~ I L I I J / \ G ~ !'
L /. , (' I J ,/ I' { c. L! / i _ , I ,
L i l[(I '" U {J [I ~ /a i ( L (( jJ, ,(Ie Ox /1 L~ ,.. j 0- (. 4' I. I I C (/ j)Je J !~
J I
~
Ii:
~. .---~-- G /
<<P J kc ( L ~- (~l U,:. '- -f[ J /'U f" c / I I' ~cll {I '/Lf/?{
. .... ~ ' c
/,
l~-=j r -1/ (~L)l /1, '- 1 /) (J:d{ j ('-I
f tL { I I )0.J
I L JvJ L J C[ ~( j{ "
(-A'-Z--
I
-- , ( , /'I v{j \..[ I /l1. lfliC LL~16
(Ic...._.\ Y [zc L Lj)() \... / /L I (7 ... C. /, ...
L-l ,i'-I_ el'l
I \ I Ii "..
t_~}>
/?'r'o..
//~\ {C L/hul ,1 ,l /7 L (~'] L ilL ~ /)1__ ' G)l/t \- L- \ \
(1r;;. i \ f / /
\, t/C/ <; VL 1 ...<. ,. - //, '--
'----
/~
/ I I j
! i ( J r J
" ./ : / / { I t .1: /J trtr-~~~r- I /( t t
........,- I I I") I' 1', J t t.. [ .):
\f.- ~ ..... '--.....- / L_ I" \ -L C t' ~. -
i J
I G;{ -
( J--{ I It .,d , / ( / / I ,. I I ,
/; ~ 1-"~ \ ~I
! '-- ~ -. \-{ , lU...ft' .
- \ -
j 'I
, ...
I ~71 L/"L / \.i- i .,.., )(~{ /"/ ! rf7 (1 i
/, i (. ) ~ 1. I //(//1 - l),~ '" / /,
I ' '--/ -.-' _(. -I.. .
/./~, r /'"...1 /i 1 ,1 /-".. .~ '. -
t (If" ~rf-+f:rt7DrtD::1r" \ /\;J /" , / ~\, -~"'---'C~'\-~-~1Z:: ~'-
. (;' r~ /' -ft-- --17. : L ~ r ~. _ V-c L. ~,1' I D ~ V. \.... .A" i' 'f-.-t.T~ 'l..r-+-il .. f -!...l-)~;:J{. I. r- ,
~-/ '
h#~l'(~~:.!./> -:,-;1.J~::'r't~~'1::.'t:'fd~~t,yf~ty~::~:t~~=~-:t~~rr::i~~~:r.:r::r~
u -.-------
.
~~~;o-~~'-:~: ,fh~{ l/il~i~if1t:~~:Jt~~t~~(;;/(t!~L~ir!~~-;~~~rJtt
I
(~) '-71 ~ 110 Ll )A: ('r? - , fe' , I /1 It' I,
~/ (.1:1 ) ( - L I I ,~ ' '
I,
l - i '
( /
(f\{{ /t I 'C\ L/! I ,. .( I ,
cl I I LL I /hJ,j I ! ' ./ / \
/A..7 . J \ L I ( , ~ \
(' l-. '- )
/ , 1/
CI
G I - I I) ,
If/f! fie ; . - -/-.. . --. J (L/../.. ' /, 4-
:~ i I ~ L / -i { ( ""--;-1- t . --t-r~;- I~.
<... - '
./
I
_ ~=1=H- J f-/-{0; ( r
tJ/l, 'i ..J,-"Z '- ,
fir -r~'E~~-+~ r-~-:oJ~~' 'f'. .'- I( -/~t'~~:J5t-+:;j/L-'1<-
,.. j .,., -----t-" -------10 'f"~ '. './ . -,- . -- ----
.. '-
.
",...--,,",
I ~ \(.',-
jl~~ -----r~ l t I .C ( Ii '\.. .. , ( / l _i ~,
~ t. '- \.f .. I
~ \.. l. .\ ' ---' "
" ~ ~ \
"--- /
{ \ ,-.I /"i I ' I I ! I (" I, cJ / ~ ;
( ~._1c \.. , Iv ( \..( ( t I )
iV -----n- ,~ I J \ ~ l
\ ~ f. ((,~" . ( - ') -f ~ \ ( (\ (-t -)J I J '---" " ,
I - , (, -.l ;-"., '\ l \.. ~ , H / '. ,{ I
I '- .:!,
\ '\ .
'--,.- /'
{\ \" -1\' (k;+~ C~l~\..L\ (.(...~( , i\.. ! I t '-..{
(reI -+ 'I
l l. 'L I, I l I
~.,-.' ....,---'-.
'--' I +-.,.
C \, L'l t L i ...\ (l L l,- ) I \ \, ! l '- {l- { (-1 l I (
"......... ~ ~ \ ~-.-' ,,-. 1 l..
'-)
d_\...-, t),. - -
? I ;:: '-..., S' \ L. ,,--'C, ',,- ~__l :> ~
~S) J~ H}0~ ~~ ~~ ~ b-<>
~a-Y\~ SliN b~
'1)( ) _J-c.-' \ \ ,-l ~) 5 ,f- ~_____n _____ ___.____. (1 ~
Ej 0 ~-------~ I \'1'i 6
~-~
..,- _n_L2~~~!r&L..~~__________
.-- ' \ ' -----
I ", \; \..~
- \.- ( ,_f
\ r--
_ 0\n\'- (2~r) I
_ __~ C;
'-- -- ___ h____ _ _ -------
r;-'''\ ~ l ~ L l ' \.:' '-- ----- - --- -
j 0,d
'-.;-.__/ ,-\ ~ ;L:.
',,-_ ""iA /) ~--r---r:_~
- - ~ ------------------
.--
I"" 1 .---
! 1 \ \_ l"'" I '\-\-'---'