HomeMy WebLinkAbout1995-0555SEARS_SHUTTLEWORTH.95-11-23
I; ~ . " ONTARIO EMPLOYES DE LA COURONNE ()\~
\>~
, , -~- ; CROWN EMPLOYEES DE L'ONTARIO W
1111 GRIEVANCE COMMISSION DE .--, ('1'\ \
c"'"
SETTLEMENT REGLEMENT ,,(.J
BOARD DES GRIEFS
180 DUNDAS STREET WEST SUITE 2100 TORONTO ONTARIO M5G IZ8 TELEPHONE/TI!.LI!.PHONE (476) 326-1388
780 RUE DUNDAS OUEST BUREAU 2100 TORONTO (ONTARIO) MSG lZ8 FACSIMILE ITI!.LI!.COPIE (416) 326-1396
rR-----.~._~-;:rI
,- -."", .""E~
~fi~~ ~"' U GSB#
... ...ol\.......-/;.~ ~. - ~ .,Jil 555/95, 556/95, 712/95
j OPSEU# 95B984, 95B985, 95D081, 95D082
1 3
i IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
CRe -
GRiE\, , ,- nLEivlENT I
BOAD,O ' Under
- -"---_____1
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
OPSEU (Sears/Shuttleworth)
Grievor
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of Community & Social Services)
Employer
BEFORE W Kaplan Vice-Chairperson
FOR THE J Paul
GRIEVOR Grievance Officer
ontario Public Service Employees Union
FOR THE M Gottesman
EMPLOYER Counsel
Legal Services Branch
Ministry of Community & Social Services
HEARING November 15, 1995
.
GSB# 555/95/ 556/95/ 712/95
OPSEU# 95B984, 95B985, 950081, 950082
BOARD ORDER
Attached is the Memorandum of Settlement which the parties
agreed would be made an Order of the Board
DATED at Toronto, this 23rd day of November, 1995
/;?/ ----------
W Kaplan, Vice-Chairperson
--
Memorandum of Settlement
Between
Adult OccupatIOnal Ce ntre Edgar
- and -
OPSEU, Local 321
(Gnevances of Sears and Shuttleworth)
In full and final settlement of the two gnevances dated -April 24, 1995,
GSB #0555/95, 0556/95 and the two grievances, Shuttleworth, May 8,
1995 and Sears, May 11, 1995, GSB # 0712/95, the oartles agree to the
follOWing
1 The employer acknowledges, as provided for In ArtIcle A 1 2 of the
Collective Agreement, that "there shall be no dlscnmination or
harassment practIsed by reason of an employee's membership or activity
in the union"
2 The employer commits to abide by Article A 1 2 of the Collective
Agreement and further confirms that it will take no retaliatory actIon
against either of the grievors for union actiVIty now or In the future
3 The employer acknowledges that it has the responsibility, when
adVised by the union, union members, or anyone else, of the posSIbility of
a VIolation of the WDHP or Article A, to take such immediate investigatory
action as may be appropriate and to take all appropnate remedial steps
4 The employer acknowledges In the circumstances of thiS case that It
was adVised by Mr Sears and Mr Shuttleworth of certain alleged
,
Violations of Article A and/or the WDHP but failed to take all appropriate
2
action as It was required to do Moreover, the employer expresses Its
regret for Its dIsclosure of certain information received by It In
confidence and undertakes to ensure that this mistake is not repeated In
addition, the employer acknowledges that t:le grievors, In their capacIty
as union officials, were exercising their role by bringing these concerns
to the attention of management.
S The employer and the union mutually acknowledge that they both have
the responsibility for ensunng a harassemclt-free workplace
6 The employer will, within ninety days of the signing of these Minutes
of Settlement, provide a training course, of at least one day's duration, on
management and union responsibilities with respect to ArtIcle A and the
WDHP ThiS course will be attended by the Administrator, Assistant
Administrator, and Director of Human Resources The union undertakes to
send at least two members of the executive, two stewards and one
member of the Health and Safety Committee to the course, and both
grlevors
7 The provIsion and agenda of the course shall be the subject of
immediate diSCUSSion between the parties In the ERe
8 If the parties are unable to agree on the course provider and agenda,
that matter shall be referred to WillIam Kaplan In a process of final offer
selection
9 Both partIes commit, henceforth, to work together In a Spirit of
cooperation and good will as they go about addressing the issues covered
.
3
by these Minutes of Settlement
10 A typed copy of these Minutes of Settlement will be posted In the
workplace for ten days
1 1 These Minutes of Settlement can, at the request of eIther party, be
made an order of the Board
12 The parties request that Wilham Kaplan remain sel7ed with respect
to these Minutes of Settlement
DA TED at Toronto this 15th day of November 1995
"R Sh uttleworth" "L Clllls"
--------------~------- ----------------------
"A Sears" "s Gilchrist"
---------------------- ----------------------
"Jim Paul" "M Gottesman"
-------------------- ----------------------
&
lV
I fV\ e v~ u /~ ~J\~ ----- I '" \::' \1\" /~ e ., +
'-..-,
.......
(? c tw e -e ..-.
H "A ~ \-\- o c c v~ y1 "" " " - ~ \ (~/~~ 2
C V""- c.. s ~ ')
/'
-- c; ,,-""..^ -
o f? '7 c:;V\- Lu<.-\. )Z\
f
- -- - --- -- ~ '
rJ ::J ..-" - "" '\:...... ..., ~ ", (., - .... / '")
.;)
-k:: )t",.r.\-1\e~ /~
~ \^- ~ ~\l v'~A 't'~-\ -,~ t1l""'^c~
~ iJ,
o~ 1"'-G ~ u <., I ,e </ ,," c ,..;, "J - \-r .-l. Af" \ z-'~ (,,,,,.
r;") '{'-, ;fl: 0'5' c; c; (q S-- ) U '5- )-r:" (C\ <;' (./\ -.. C./ \ ~(
~u S' ,e</~-( e S I .( 4 '" [",\ <" ~ <- - t-.. ( (" ~\..~ 7 &-1
() 1/ Z / q ~
V
'""^ ^./- S -t' <-... ./ '-:7 [;1/\--} ~ 4 l \ '-1.. "'" ) ~ C:-
I ,
(
{'~/D of S o ,-/"-C e 1-L be '--Z" \ l ( \.-/~ \. -'" ~ .-, /1
,
>--
..I
'^-"'S V 1.0 lC/\. h A-- 1r L \ L
e V"'- (> tv 7 -C./ I
.rr' C-' ,,- /~. ...-'
~ G~v-e '" J'Z'S[' c C
o,~ "
\-u St'-./~ ') L-,-^c \11 e --v ~ -~' '>
lfV\-v/ . ~
if(Jlu,~e.s C- ~ ~ e (,; '\ C- .......---
6 1
{-\;; cr-e S,JC -\- 9-z ~ k 0\ J ' ___ ~ cl c ^
~
~ ( _ \ ~c ~ \ C' ~ Z ') ,s CA >
.., Il^e e J'-"-p < 7 c /' <-( <, .
.!.-/
r /~ v'~ eJ.. qc,J jlJ \---. c. \ c A \L. L-g-
l""-
~</'\.-+ /( ~e ~
~( Lv II ( C h v1- Jl j" e -^- "...+
\> ~'"' Jv^ S5vve
S ~~ \ \ ,.-... 6 ,./
l.:,.e. ^" ,/\,}I-J'~'-"'~
() ev-f ('-7 ~.;
(./^-C~JP.A L. ./Y "'- f t '-'" C ---;-- C^ ./\-
7
I^-^ (' ;--l, "" J ;; ~, <P ~ ' to "" 7 \'" ~e (./\ --'\. L (
oJ
C <.> "" --- ' .\-> h: f Ii G
0C € ,-..r-f ('- 7 e --- G/\ '--;l G;.- ,
-->
/">
IV ~( f-e A \ z ~ ~ C"-' \ (~ c..
<- I
"-17
J
Or \-- \~_~e/ ~~~_~S~~+-
/ .rc e ,~ e -A CA ~ J
~) c:./\.. C. ~ C. '-'\
t~ vV'~ \. ~ \l e V'v ~ ~ \ l"'--\-v-)
V\), '" L -S .~ h "r l-- e c.; \ r? ..-' '-' .-' 9 ~ ~/
.-€ l e./ c~
~ '+--- ~.A:
"^- l- -h./' +; '-^ V -A...J 0..../
(.......... e
c..A ^ L (.; l./"-
, l \ J -e > ~v, -\- (+-
~ 1 -/ V- C ~ ,,< ~ e ~
'-1 .e e .,..... {i ( 7 e
t-e .0 f' .,..~J,J, \ ~;;'5 ,{ J' J l"
," __, vl^ e"'" --c ~ ' e 1
'^ V'-). ,'_ r
-~. _.~-_. --.--
,\-e -,,' L- <A. ./'- p ~G,r'./) ~ ~ c>' ~) ( ./0 c--
l/' "^ ~ (./ /'-- [ V' I
...e lic) /0 r ~e l, l b c:Cr C\ J(<:-(~.,L~
("$-" ' L '
u/ A./ ~ \e A
V i-v- \ (.c > LA C v....
cq-- he uv\,/?0'r -0J
L
l V'" "^^ -e vl L ..... tc ( 0/1. JY C' .) "" .\-z ~7 v-. ( he ~ 0-...>-
~ -e V'L r (' [- (/L "'- h- "'" -"."^ '-Z ~'(e-
vM...j
h &zP ..--c VV"-'" O\., <>'\ l ~
C^ \ \
tAf("f/L-". " . L,
.~e e ./""<( (~ 7 e ./ CA ( k-AC ~ \< e-\ ~{' '5 \ ...-..
S
~e ((./(<-^ v"-<;.~~' C:.> cC} .~'-> CU'I..) e
u-.du,j.-"d.. k7 v/'vt J (
(~ -
l ~ /_ ~ ;/'J -... c., I
! \
~
cA ~ ~ l ~ Y\ '--' 5 L, -'\ (1\ e '-- v '- -' h c ~ (c'.-/ ~'-l \_____
~ ~({cs-cv( U'-0(~.I(--S c:0- I~t\((e 4
~./\-t :J-~ \ (C" v~ I-v
LA"; u{ I C- C;:\l J;;s ,,'r;' v:' 1+.0:
tv- ~'-e.. ~ ~ c-h L~ c/\. <; ( \- -./ ~ t ~l '-'\' C"' vi.
~ J.. C '--""- <--J .~
. . t"e (,-t '-/e./ .
(;5 . ^'\ c. Je ~ ./<" -', f'l' e~ f-"" 5 S. e" \ h /?" S -^,"..\- '1c. - ~
~~8~t: ~~ t>f'~.~"'" ~
1 l ~ r- r~ / {n \ ~ l "'\ ~ "'""" ""'" +, (. --. Y?' e ('-'T vi (,.? ( .t- \ ~
..;Al)C '-}V\......-c. c ---'-= rz... '- I
n.1 /') ~-,,*' :--~-'tJn M /h..~ .k '-""'\.....{ p-" f~ l< C-J rc cJ -'" ~'-'\ ~
C (; ~ c/' f' '"' ( l;: -' '- (: . '.
r "'+- 01.) ""\. l.j t-z,. \( e (S '""-C + o/?" f <""'~ h ~ ~::'~t~:\'~.:'-< h < c:? ---I t~ 7 ~ - /
~ ~-c ~~p((..7e~ c-"_____Jl.. ke G/\-'l('~
.f'A. '-" ~ </\.11) "-,,> L (, -...C ---L \ r' c/ ~ r ~ c, +'" c-,/
k,c. ~ Cc"tJc-t::;~'r 5/<--5; ~ I ({ ~ b ~~
e '^-5 '-'\. /, V\. ') "" L.,,,,, /~ SJ ~ c" --A-- -- Lc ~ ~ <- __ ("-
If""L ~ - ~~Vf5
9- ~ e "" ,^,,(d c ? c- vv \ II "" J." \ -, '^ \ ., ~ ~ vi. "'7 .>
c9 ~ r" 5 I ) -'\. \ ~ (Q.. hue ~N1, V\ ..., h <, \ St-
'f r. J( J\.z
/ '-'"
S-e Hl C" ~ e",,' 01 "'" 1v--e.." \ """' \ _ j C C -\ -- 'E:' / '--- ~
u\t- (('~ ,+ O"-e d"'71<, d""-......-hc-.. c-,,- ·
d <' \_ J
:/VI .A '^ ""~ \ e ./""\ (' -.. + C"\. -'"'- J J\. -'\ l l........... J(: ~r (~ (lr, I ( rf
(/'J \ ~ V7 s!? e c J,- -/-rJ Avhc\-c 1'-0
A- i:- V GV vtJ [-f- yO
CA (fz~eg\ ~7
.
'"0 e C<::- v'\. / _\ e uv \ f ( l-? e h C- '''7,
jr)\ ~ t -'\ l S ~ h./ I m 50- \ ~ ~""\-t r1-d V\ l ,-Ll \~-h.:r
, /
v? IV(: G h../ c... Cj- ~ ~q......... v1 r- s c. ~--C ~S ~G
(}\. /\ L L......... U\ ~J e ./ h (( ~ ~ -tv s e '^- Jt... 0-t- ( -C~~+-
~ r.-.e ~ ~ -.e -- ':> C.q- .~ e -e .l( ~ ~ ---'\. n '-''e ~0
/
5 ~ '-U ~ -..A s C~..-..~ ?- -. e ,/V\.. ~ ~ l, -e -- c 9- ~ rJ
'---
(h~ lk -r -~0h [,-" ~ """-l t-f- e e h: ~ e c-c V\./ .> f
. (
O\..""'-cA ~(.J- ~/\l:'00J~ ~/5
8" ~e r /" v ~ ~ { ( '-"\. """-,,,,-c:..-A.... o ) e ~.c.{c-... c C)- he
~.~ L,J~ G +- C Cf- .
s4 ~ ( (
CCv\. ../)~ Lye ~e v( VV\ V\..<.. c:>~ c.. ~ ~
.
c) l.> { '-- ~ .s l (. ""'- c"e J-v-e e~ -\..e~ r-"- h <"" 5 ' --.
h-<- <S-YCC
~\ ~1- ~~ f",/h(",,5> C1....r-c '--\ ~ ~ S ( c -b
V
\0
J
6/\. re '^ / S G- (l' ~ ~, ,). '" / ../\ ...-., J\
LA \.;-( e CL j
. . \ l G -
o ';, -e ",..0- "'- \ _ ___ J"\ -\ /'" v' \t-z./ > L...."'"' e.--
UV,ll,--'~ \(-((--.-
JC Q- e / /"! J\. D 1-
.Cf
Q q, ~"" l c,'~./
C/1 ~ fr'UC <,,$ S ( )
5el-{'cPC- ---
\.D 0L~ l~/~e> { c vV' if' ,-\- I L,..,..../'-c e Gc., - ~ ( -\u
z- '(' v ,-\--- .......--
bSe~C-../ /'
l./"'... -
vv v- ~ i.-
e c ere /' <-"- -\< ( --.... V' /,-./1. Y c .It <./" L { ( <-.-'\. S - --... c -
/
S -V "^ .((J/i ~>' ~ ') ~e.. \.'5>""'C>
SU /\. ' -^'? - .
ccV<./ ~ tA.. ~ \-'-<1:'')6 ~ V'" c-" ~tz..s
7
c 'I: y 11 e oI'^- e -^-\--
Ht','f!:LA
H lie of 7 (cr <;-c ~<'~<"+
J ~ q
~0 5e JV\. ,,,,,,, ~ S c
1 t
\
~ ~ \ l l,c -h ~ l '" -b- <:: V'" c.. <./ Ie f {"" C(
{J'" u '
l}-t/ ' C ./"- vZ7>
~6)e rj\J\ ~ ./\ __ 'r ,> q ~ e iD e'''' e -"- -\- ,v\ ../\-
,7.- ,,;~
CA.'~ ~ 9- ~ ~ L-,e ~Vcj
~e .rr '(U'e)> ~ t' l e-/ (.0.' ~
CA"" u/~e./ ~g- \--e fJ~V'-../ J -
(t-/ t--- ,.;, .rC c;.- ..... -e > -\- ----. -.. 1- VV \ \ " l.... ....--..
l> ~
t v<. -" ~ V"" '> ( (' c-l-
(. t- r l "'- '-^ JT ~V\ ("" 5 c ,-Z t'
_ _ _ tz,- \- ~_l--:'. ~ < (q- 5< I~I t' ~~+ -
/' __ e,e.,
() 0(2d) ?^ '\-- 1'0 /v~ b '^ +- itS- ~," l S- \--- J~7 ,CJ-----
C'J0A~~(/ lp\.~ S
L- -
II' ( .......
,
/-
-
\s. \' 'C-s lO~ ~ ~ f\l1
f(\CJf'> \-u Gw 11L