The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1996-0750WITHER97_01_22 ONTARIO EMPLOYES DE LA COURONNE CROWN EMPLOYEES DEL 'ONTARIO ~ GRIEVANCE COMMISSION DE 1111 , SETTLEMENT REGLEMENT BOARD DES GRIEFS 180 DUNDAS STREET WEST SUITE 2100 TORONTO ONTARIO M5G IZ8 TELEPHONE ITELEPHONE 14161 ,26 388 180 RUE DUNDAS OUEST BUREAU 2100 TORONTO (ONTARIO) M5G lZ8 FACSIMILE TELE:COPJE (416 126-1396 GSB # 750/96 OPSEU # 960710 IN THE MATTER OP AN ARBITRATION Under THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT Before THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD BETWEEN OPSEU (Wither) Grievor - and - The Crown in Right of Ontario (Ministry of Community & Social Services) Employer BEFORE: F Briggs Vice-Chairperson FOR THE R Murdock GRIEVOR Counsel Ryder, Wright, Blair & Doyle Barristers & Solicitors FOR THE K Renison EMPLOYER Counsel Legal Services Branch Ministry of Community & Social Services HEARING January 22, 1997 - BOARD ORDER Attached is the Memorandum of Settlement which the parties agreed would be made an Order of the Board DATED at Toronto, this 22nd day of January, 1997 ~ <-- \") \~ \ \.;: \,' '\ So } <\{, ~i:. ~ 'T 11 E ~ "-\ M \ \ C "- (,~ \~\ C r 1',- \. ,- \J ~~ \ \ ( \ \ ~ ~ I' ~ \. \ \ \ \ '- ,"Z.. \ ,=: \., 1\ ~ ~ \, J C \ T L_J~ \', C I' \ \.~ ~.. \~ k l~ ,"'"' \":; c.. "\ \}, E 'C \\-~ o i'-.J " 1\ ~ '0 'y v'~ \._ \ c.... c: ~-::.. ,,,-'v' \.,~ \ ~\? L. 0 'l c:. \.. ) '-J \' i C. ( '0 C, i\\ e \ \. \ f\.-,-~ ') ...., l. ~I:""\ ~~ ,-' ("/ ~ \ - (. - \"'- \ '\ \-\ C=.. c '\<.-c \..'-J ~. \ ~ \d- \ G" -T (., \-.- l (~r\~\ ~\ (' l 'f1\. \ \, \ 'S 'I i'~j Q ~ "- c ."" ~,-,-,~ \ '1 j c^- ((t ~ c:.; ~ d"~ ~ i2 K.-l ,-Cl j \:=. ~ '('- \J \ 0 ~ ~~?- t\ \ N v\. -r S ') () p s ~ \\ L- t. 1\ b;.. NT \ ~ e.- '\) G-\~-\- \ e ,-, o~c: ?- E: t~ ~'d c::,~. \-\- \,t t ~ \ S c;:~ Q It. ,/ ~\'\ ~L (' ,'- i~ \ c \ \ 0 ~\.. '"'~ 1 <<~(\'\ S \. \ ~ e ~ ~ t\ \ ~"I'\"-~~' 1- \ s ~ I t~c/ '-~\- .~ \' ~ C~(\\..~\.-\ O~ \? \)~ ~_ \ '-"-LA'-CJ- see \~UG \i\i,C:<\\ ~~~~ \~ \.- t "-"-' L"'Z {\. H ''Z \!"'--... c ~ -t ,<2._ (" \ v \---...) __ -i -...) ). \ \" 3, (1 '- \ '-\ ,,( ~ ~ '-\: -"- (- ~ ~ ~ '~ \ S c I r, ~ ,e') L '-" ~i L i)" ~ I \ xl'^,- . ') .....:-...--^,--,<-- \'~ I I c\ c\ ~ \ 2) '-'- ~t\ ~~"'-\.~C"'-'-~ \'l ; ~\ \r~_ L ~.~ ~ '\ \ c, "J "<- i---- \.''-J '- \ \ v,- t\" ( 'v "~~- \h ~~~ \ ~- -\:- \ ~-\~ C ~_ \.)\.. \ ':> ,x"\. \,) ') c'- \ '-\... \..:'- r- 'tl \. -J \ '- \\ 't' C \ '-\ C\ 0 c"-,<"-cl. ,"-~ \~\c (Z:_ \ '\- '-..".J .t\~, C,,_ \ t: r\-~4-:: ~ 1-- \. \ ~ '- '~\ "-c ( ,~') t '- \ \ 0 "'- .- (\ ~ --\ \~- l J (' \ ~~ '- ( L- \ '5 ) '--"- ~ \1-:-.. \j'"C '\ ",--- ;.- u'~ l '- \:::;...\.. \~ \ C' ci- '- C' \-~ '>s (y"', l ~ \ \'-~ .r-.... C ( ~ ,\'\. 1,\'" \. ,''' C ,1\ C] --r \~ '- '>L- t L (' 1 ~ ., (,- \\ C\. -l< '-1\ L,\ I (\. (:~ "~\? \ t...V''-' ~ '-j \ C I \\ ( 11'1 \.,'''-- \-\'\'( -'-\: \J( - '-\ l ~"c\.. \l\~ \, \ t2 ~ I 1- <; -1 5 D Il~ , P ~ "). \ ,2) . r:- (~'L -\ "'-'-, \f'" A~' (' A" \:,~ ~y ,.. l i)~) \ ,\ S \ 0,,- _ ,'he ex" \ ~ ~ ('.,'2. \..~ \ \ \ '{\. c \- c -~ C IL.... -i<. .)(-.: r, \. O)--..\. \1 l3) . \\. '-->.....) C' \ .\-\ .$. ,"'- C'\~ (") ~ () le_ '-J v'f\. t\t',,-,- ~, (t. V\'- 0'- t\ c'^ c.~~\. ~--.iL~ ~.\- ('.) (iJ2:) ~ 'K.~ F-> (, \..A.>.) \ \ \ b--e. "\.... ..\.- \ l 1\ \' : S \ J {le c\ }) ~ \ V~ (..;)"'- \ ~- ~ (~~ c>-:~,c. ()l~- \ .~.....(l'~,-.c~ \ c '~ C_ C/\y~ \. 0>-- \ i\ 0_,,\ \- \') \~ Q '--'- \\ \ CrY\. ~$'-tj(,.,;;""\\\<,, , ~ r v , '0 ~ (} :~_IL T-\-~ C ~ \ ~ \... c,,~~ R e \ f'\ ') + (~.... \<2 ('\'\ Y C'\T \ \.\) _ ~ ~ ~L, -\\ ~ ~'" ()'__l...- ~ ~'\.D",'\.) \ ~~\ ~, w\".Q.. vvt -R c~ \--t\0i. c.~ \. ~ .~ r'L ~"o--: S \.A 0 \ c.... \-Q(t w tJ I\-\- ~ '? C'), \ \ C-J (^'{~ '~ \\"\, 'f\ \ ~ +- 1',- \:) S +- (J...- f'- cL c>{~ s G ~ L ov\. J \A..C- .y- o, 0-6.. C^-o"'- O-.-L ~ f'. C)'"\N t ~ d. J -Q_ ,~'2.." t ~ c-. 1- ~, v...J,- t-~ '"^- CJ \ c,..~\-. \ ("'.J'r. G ~_ ~:; (~'- '\ cl \J\) 0 \-\ P ~ 6 \ \ ~ '1 Q" C\.. S T c"- .""'--OtLClS 11\ ~ \:?. \2. '::, ~ J t \ l'\ CA \ ~ ('(\ ,3 S, c" > \.Iv' \: D~ ~ I '\ Y ~C~ ~ J ~ .~ f \ -'2... \) 0,'- \ V\. t ~ .~ d'~_ ('0.. 0__\-\ QY-k:..l ,,~_ c\ \~__Rc. ~ c) C>._~~ ?'\ .B ~.") ~ ~ ~ C \J L ~ \ f'.. ') T cJ..'\ C "",-\-' ,"-. \- , -1.'k c.~,c ~.'~ \.. \~ "\.."- \ \ 'D .~- '-) \ '- ~- \\ ~ V ~ I" ~ \' '--\\l1~J ~ c cC\-"f~~-",,-'t~ \...'" \') \'\ \"J l- \ ~\ 1'\\\\J c'-\"C~ CC'--l'\',;~J\\}\ ( \~ \/_,~'-"-- ~,,- D \-\ ~ \\ ( \ \ ('j ( - "c l '; <~ \. ~l ,-c\.c,~c\S <....:- 't- "-- (~ f,,- ('\..~'-..... ~ \ x l ~" ('.. \. 1;'- cj ~ '-- ,\ \ ~h '- l \'Y"-\\\ ~_ "tl:-(~. i.-\ '-) ,\'\ '--'_':~\..Jj \ \ - j --\ c\ (~'1 "~\'-(\ \ \ ~ 1...\ Ii l ~ '- G 1.. \.. \..J ~ \ ~, \. ~ ,_ \ G,-- f-.:.- '- (~-1 \.\. -~ '\ C c \ - I ' c \ t,--"-,,," \) '- '--1i ~ \ '-.\ f' ~" Ie,,'. C""'-C ~ l.. C ~'~j \" '\-' C>.... C./ ~--- t ~""\ ( -'-... ,\ \ Y\ ~ I \ I.- r\ ~ l.\. G- ~f-'<-CT \v~~ \ k-'L C J ~ \- ~ (, { ~,~ \ Q\ ~I'"t c,--t e ~f\ei'\ t . , -\-\ ~ ~_'\~ \ OJ ct~< \..."-.), \ \ ru....'~( '-.\ (:.!- ~~.;"L (i'i~ .~. C~2.-1 <t ,-'("':"1 -"''''j\ \ c ~ V_ ",_' j ~ '\~5 \. ~ \\. ~'\ ~ \ ,~ \ \ ~ _.t\.._~- ~~ C:J \ \ 0.) ~'-~ I 1 \. j r \ ~~b C\q~ \.).J '\::J \-1 P - 1- \VV~j~~-l j <<t \ 0-1-" \Q'\ci~.J' A -j '--.:--.....z t (, \ qc{ ~ .I) \ <:: f""\ 'S ~ c\..\ \ ~--\-\- ~I~ ) ~ r ~ (\. '( <; c r \\ {\CA."\'j \ ~-r:\ -c~ ~ f\'\. ~ ~ 2...\ ('\ ~~ ~ L\ c:....\- i A \ 9.q S -' \)J \~ \-\ \-'J -c \j \ ~~ ~ "C.L tJ \ -s c) 0:) ,-,:cr.. '\ ~~<.J," \ \ \) l qq l ' , \' 3 G-S{'-c~'-.{'-- k (,~i'..d i s ~ n ~,-J6 ,} fLc,,~ (, \~~ \\) lq '\. s- ~~^' tJ . ~ f'>. ~~ . , 0,- \ Q... l') .,.. \. ~~ , - \. '-- C \""'-". 1 \s'C\-b \ ~\:2 <. \~ "- ~ cl \ .s: C {j \ \ ;\,CY:J f'\\ ~ '"J.. '1 ~()"-E'S - , ~~~ St- ~'~! _ ~~-?;\J \9:~ j- s ~ ~ ~cl \:J,~ b M Q ~- -\- ; '" ~ f'.. C.it- e....s D \J\j, t~ ~cl ~ 1S~_c^...J~~ q (-\\\ --\~ .\-\ ~\cS o &(\.'0~ ~J (::'j~_ 'S u,-,6 ~'\\.~ "\1 ~-c1 b~) tk ('...J~ '\ ~0 Cf'L "\' Q..\ 0- ~e A \- c' lli~ ('.,\c>-- t\ $ _ It 1\ , 0--$ Q ,,,\ '\-~ \.!,--t\ c~~\.-Lcl \. ~ -I.(JK . C~\{"" 6- \ \- -'C ~s t:- '{.. C ( () \ l2.. t\ ~L, d_c\..- \- ~(i :J ''^-\.:j ~ - J I C't c\. (, ,~v~(,N'\,j... S C\.l' \ ~_ "" c- \~_ t-~ ~ \' ,,~.~ ~2.. _, \ \ ~\\Q-L\, ''"'''C'J v"-QJ\e j ('6,\ 0 '5 $ l1 C'( l.. \ ~ LJ ~ - "'- \ [, I ~ <i. q l F \ ,~if' \\ ",'\S_ s ~ (h'\.S ~ '~) '\ \~ ~. \: \ \ Q) -~ '-, .I', ~ ~ '-' ',- \ \ 52--- "",,,-- C -~ v '- ~'\'-. '\ \1 "( ~ j C -,- \"<J --.' (' ':-:':. ,~_" ':'l (, ,;""'- ~l ..\ I \ \-' - \ , ' I) \ '<- \\ -\ ' \ ,-"t-' \ '- "- V \ \ ," '~, J S '-x-, \) ~ {2, C \' ~ C\\~ C ~ \ \ Q l. ~" '-~ I ....___A'-..........r '- \...J - \ ~'.\ ^ '-- t. r...... \: I... . . ,1,\ ~ ).... '\ 0-C- '1-."- C ,__ \ ~ c\. \ ~~ "",\ ~ c,:...\::". \ '- "'-- ~ "_ '\:.:. \ \ C \=--- ( \. \, \. r'... \ 0 '-- ~,l.) '1 k\ ~ <:. ~ ) ~ '--, 'n ") "'-- \. \- .-\-- (\ \-~-'0.. G' \ \c c:\- \. '-~ _ he J' 't:. "- i 1'- E- ,\,1'" j') ,'" ' ~~ \.i'--:\-<<->- ~ ('- ~ ~ ,~_ tt \.\.2. (f\,. ~ (,.~ (, \ \~ ~ ~ "-I~\ '<_ '--' (\,~ j , ' c" \ \~ t' ~ v'-,s '\:-C_ \"\:..., "4'-'~ , <\ '--_\ C>.- \: {-~ - r-~ \~'- c \ \ L~,j" ~ ~ \:J ~ \.,--c'~~J \ t ) \ S c~ I ~ (S'C)/9~ .-- ,---.,. \\ '-\ l .. \) '-- \:-- ( y" C,-- -I -- '\ \~) ( \ (~ C J r:; f' ~- (y\ 0 - \ r\. 5 5" \ z..? (\. c C"- \ -K \ v\ '1 \ \ '-Q.. v\" {.J~ i "- -\- o_'\- \. Cf'-.. C 1- ,.~"\ \ S (',--- '- -r -E~L_" '- ~ , \ \- ~ \ ~ \ j C'__ C' ( "~ ~ 0 '" ~ ~ \- ~ V"\. ~ \ \ t ~ \ ~,c, '''ie-iL O--!,- i_A "f"-. 0- 0. \', kolu~ ,) & ~ ~\S C~ ~d ~ c-\- ~cL D" \- \"" c:>L~~\- v ~~ ',- s J.... 2- D\' o':j /9.&- ~ C-"",-C-l":j " '\ '\ ., / . /j ,,}' l i;/~ ~ ~ / ~~ ~:/ )4~ . · ~ ~ gt&/.- ".~~ ~\~0~- u\-)3 CC ~ ~ ;/ ~ / LI/// _ -- f k ~\ ~cfX-l~ ~- ~~ '\;:: 'f-.. G\ \ I' . ! I .t- Th~ COVY\flalV}~ I \ f I ~ ~,- \ " It r C\T \ l \ '( ( '17 the il J\ Ilu c\ I . . nk t+t \ l...l.. IU \ l\!\~J yctlX cc (npi ")\ nt th(\.l \ h2l1 <-.. ,.>' J.. c l yc II \1 \ t\ 't \\J\::'r k+~<~c \.. ~ (\\y Cl (llL~ ~- Dr (~Cill ~t I~- '-t' x (ted I kc-'(..c: c. yeti II) c'J()Y 'v\i..'j -'J( (~ i-)'Y l' ~\-t- .k:CIl\ 'n. '/"- l\ '\\\\~ CJ ny , YU.l hcl~C 11' 'I ,\;~,'((:I -\Lz_-,t ('~\y tv,_hue' c::: ((kc\ UI (1\1 \"z-'\ + WIll IX C'\' ~("--:kt\~ V'i d y\tt \C 1~ \- \ 1- cJ\ d IT rl-~ni cr 'i-he- L k-..} -.,-J - \ W b H- P pc'\lLj <_~ II I'...(J C k\ ) , " V-. ! -T'n( r I~ :'1 I i i ~ j I I \ I , , ) I .. / I ' , ,/ I \ f , ( I j , \ 1 f\.,,'l'~\./ I I 'I '< , I 1 I I \ i V" I k r~X( \ \ I, (~:i1-~O~1,~t) , I I ./ \: It" \ I( t \ ( II ! h \ 1 ' c.. ," I \ \ ,\ (( \\ \' (./ I -:./ I II/lJ I I X\I \l 11$ (:tz.~J(brdt") c C,:,( Jut. e ,5; .~ \'( I'/l \ n l "+rj C (I .411 "'1"(\ LL ,'.,j.J . I \,- I~CIIIII l.'l)ll'-'\ (,) \ I C '- \.. \ ~\ "'_1: \ '_ (( ~ I c~l "-L ~ ~c l \ \'c\..,-kct ( i hcJ ,"JI I\. -r, +l' I " iL t....lll '1-) I ~ 1", \ \.. t..... J ..-' +b: \\~ D H I) $ \ c. <Jt'C\ I 01 the I"') i r 1\ ('...:;r'I ....J "" l\ ,. /1,/\ ct c · ~. j , - =-luI'Urc) c- c-t l~l C , I f\\~j (c\LL\ + I (i my rl "'Y\('("~ 1 1 \...1 \ _,j 1--:. ' ( /' / ..- L '"" ! A 'I '<t---: ___..--.... , ') /.'. ,"" ! ';': -bU-..-'~-<":_ _~:'.:--c../~~~ L; ~r\ L" \ .t~ C 1-....:.:- ""'- 1..... --CSB Hie Nu. 750/96: i - ~ THE MAT 1I'.l{ Oil' A GRlEVANC-FL. ,--Bl?1tORli' TIJR - jiB~'.T.\NCE SETTLE1\mNT UOAlW- ~ ___R R T WEE N: ------ - ONTARIO P'JR',IC SERVICE EMPLOYEES UNION-- (Daniel Wither) - GrIey;or ~ - .--ancr:- ~ THF CROWN IN RIGHT OF ONTARIO - (Minis~ of tolllmunity aDd Social Sernc.ps) - ~ L~ c Ji'..mploy~ - --- -mI>>SX- - ~ - A Gnevance June 13, 1996 B Letter of DIsmIssal June 10, 1996 - C Stage II Gnevance Report June 28, 1996 - D WDHP InvestIgatIOn Report February, 1996 - E Floor Plan of Avalon Apartments and Infirmary KItchen A - ...... -2 F Documents submItted by Gnevor at Stage II 1 Letter from Mary Jane Inch October 18, 1995 . =l 2 Letter from Wendy Wither October 23, 1995 3 Letter from Terry McCreIght October 23, 1995 4 Letter from Neil Ouellette October 23, 1995 5 Letter from Brenda V olhck October 23, 1995 6 Letter from Conme Surgenov June 16, 1996 7 Letter from Shale Wnght June 17, 1996 8 Response to WDHP report from Darnel Wither 9 Drawmg of Floor Plan of Apartment G Correspondence from Deputy Mmister Sandra Lang 1 Letter to Michael CIlhs April 19, 1996 2 Letter to Darnel Wither April 19, 1996 3 Letter to Shem Jones Apnl 19, 1996 /' I ' H Notes from Pre-DIscIplmary Meetmg wIth Gnevor May 27, 1996 Ii ~ ;j;, I Notes from Meetmg wIth Complamant May 31, 1996 ,~ ) J Entployee 'OnentatI\~ orm ..../ \ ~ ' J0-J \ ' K AC~dge n~frcr . al DIrectIve #3 \ I i ! /' ~ /1 ,"-" L l~rm ,ce Appr 1,~vor Ma~ ~..// !vI / WDHP Proe ures "~ - I ..... .-' II 3- N Letter from Shelley DaVIS J ul y 21, 1996 I 0 Memo to MIke Cllhs December 19, 1996 1 , - . t _I - - ~ 1 I 'I 11 I I ,-, I I .