HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997-1182.Holliday et al.03-02-26 Order
Crown Employees Commission de ~~
Grievance Settlement reglement des griefs
Board des employes de la
Couronne
~-,...
Suite 600 Bureau 600 Ontario
180 Dundas Sl. West 180 rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto Ontario M5G 1Z8 Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388 Tel. (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396 Telec. (416) 326-1396
GSB# 1182/97 2056/97
UNION# 97B837 98C086
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontano PublIc ServIce Employees Umon
(HollIday et al ) Grievor
- and -
The Crown m RIght of Ontano
(Mimstry of TransportatIOn) Employer
BEFORE RIchard Brown Vice-Chair
FOR THE UNION Robm Gordon
Gnevance Officer
Ontano PublIc ServIce Employees Umon
FOR THE EMPLOYER Kelly Burke
Semor Counsel
Management Board Secretanat
2
ORDER
The PartIes consent to an order of the Gnevance Settlement Board as follows
Whereas the gnevors m the above matters gneved that they dId not receIve the proper
mterest m accordance wIth the formula set out m GSB decIsIOn 188/88, and
Whereas the PartIes wIsh a full and final resolutIOn of these matters on the followmg terms
wIthout prejUdICe or precedent to any other matter;
The Board therefore orders as follows,
1 The Employer shall pay the gnevors for mterest m the amounts calculated by each
mdIvIdualm the attached documents,
2 Fred Gavm's gnevance IS wIthdrawn, and no money IS owmg eIther to or from hIm m
thIS matter;
3 Rachel Laszlo IS to receIve payment of the average amount of mterest owmg,
specIfically m the amount of $625 48,
4 All payments m thIS settlement to be made no later than 60 days from the date of thIS
order
Dated at Toronto thIS 26th day of February 2003
~/
/"
/...~~1.-oof' -
fuchMd Brown
Vice-ChaIr
.............,.,.,.,
0.
I-w 'F'
U).J 00
WOj ~
0::<( 'r"
w>- :I:
1-<( ()
za. Uj
(f)
"0 0.
... 0. W
- ro 0 I-
<( 3: <(
....I <( 0
:J ,00 Ujo
:E it} Uj- >-
0:: w<( <(
0 b: ....I a. a.
0 ...........................
u., 'ol-' 0
>- (f) 'r'
W cv ....II- 00
...
U) cv ~
U) - <(z 'r"
<( t: to 1-3:
0
:E I+- m Ow
- 0 N I-Z
:z b: 'F
0 0 -
- 1.0 I- 0 u;~ 1.0 1.0
I- ~ Ww ("'} ZON N ("'}
<C ::l GI- m ..... m~' M m
....I u ~~ .JN~~ OJ
:J ~ (fj ~
() u (f) wI-
....I cv ro >z 0
<( 0:: () <(- I-
() -..
l- I"'- ~ ~' '"
m 'IF cc~ OJ
U) W m W OJ
W u.,::t: ::t: M ~~
0:: 0!Z I-
iW Z
il- 00 0
:Z z:E ~
-
N W
00 00 I-
:~~t:.. 1.0 ~
N 0.
m I-
>- 'IF
.~ ~O,;;. OJ U)
.=.~:::o.:. W
.......~. Oli' > 0::
0". ......... .
......~..~. - W
:C::<~:N C I-
~ Z
w W
'IF C)
~ 'F
W C) 0 00 -! ~
0:: M <(
~zO I- ~It} I- W
mO}
_0:: w men 0 >
.,. Ull '"' , IV' ....
~
-
~
FUJ ~
(1)-1 N
WOJ r-..
,,<( N
W>- J:
F<( U
Ze.. U)
III -
"0 0
l.. 0 ill
~ F
- 3: 0 I-
<C Z <(
-' <(
:::) CO (1)0 C
:;: ~ (1)- >-
" W<( <(
0 c: -Ie.. 0",
0 ......
u. - ~
>- III ~
W (\) N
l.. -' F'
en (\) <(Z ~
en - N
c: ro
<C - ~ 5?;
:;: 0+- C')
'''''-''''' 0 N FW
Z c: 'F Z
0 0 ..._~
I :;::; C":) FU1~O 0 M
F ~ W (JO ZC\!NO tn W
CJW
<( ~ <(..... (JO -to'F'F CO W
-I 0 " ~, ....J '~ r-.. 'F' N
:::) ~ III <( 'F'
t) 0 III WF .....
-' Q.\ ~ >z 0
<( a:: t) <(- .....
t) _.........~ ,-
F ~ l.l?ON ~
C":) OOM M
en U) en en ,to N 'F'
W ::x:: ::x:: 'F en
a:: u...... 'F' 'F'
.....
W Oz Z
F 00 0
Z Z~ ~
~--_...
C":) UJ
N F
~ <C
N ..q a::
~ I.ti I-
.0., >- N
OJ en
{'t? UJ
~.. > a::
W:
N 0 UJ
.....--.......................... I-
I.ti Z
..q W
..q
~ en c;>
UJ Cl 0 ....J <C
In <I: DC
:2Z0 NM~
'0'1 C') en I- ill
<(_0:: 0'1 en en 0 >
zeno.. ''f"" 'F 'F' ..... <C
""",-""",-- - .- ""......"".""..""....~ - '-1
.. ..................,.,.,.,.,..,._"" ....,.,.."" .......-;
I
~--"""
("?
liiw to
...J "l:t
Wco "l:t
0:::<( to
W>- ::x::
~<( t)
_ Cl.., (J)
w -
"0 e
:l- e W
..- ~ l- e F-
<( ~ Z <(
...J - 0
.::J ro 000 >-
.:a: 00-
to w< <C
.11:: !: ...Jo.. o..~
0 0 ..."""""-~->"" !
u- -' ~
:>- w to
W <>> I- "l:t
:l-
U'.) a,) ..Jz "l:t
U'.) """ <- to
... 00
<( .... I-s:
- 11)
~ - 0) Ow
- 0 N I-z
Z ... 'F'
.... ---....""""".""""""'.
0 C"-'"
0 ; I'- 1-011)11)0 0 t-
..- ro zot-~o 0 00
~ ~ W
- I- <.0 -,q'F'''F''F ~ to
:l
...J <.) <( ...J<<:l0'l:t-"F I'-
::J - w 0::: <( "IF
~ w I-
U <.) ~ I- 0
...J <>> - Z
.<( 11:: t) - I- '--~
U ."""......~~
N ..qoQON N
1- M (l)OOOM M
U'.) (I) to :cl'-NN"IF tn
W :c N N
11:: U-I- I- 'F'''F
W Oz Z
I- 00 0
z z:E :E
-
e W
... N "l:t I-
<(
:E...1XL !,f) a:::
";'..~.. 11)
6 t. N I'- I-
~~:..~. >- M (/)
CO W
.owM ;;:: 0:::
~.:'~:~; w
0 I-
...,.,.....""""".........---- Z
m -
I'- W
0 C>
~ 0 "IF ...J ~
W c:> tn ,
IX: t- i .:(
:2'zO I- I 'rNM~ F- W
mO'lmO'l
<_0::: w I O'lmmm 0 >
ZWCl.. 0::: ~ 'F'~"IF"F F- <
------ .....~_..~"""""-~_.... ..,.""......~.~~~~
-
~
I-w C"'!
Cf.l-l 'r'
Wall l.O
0::< l.O
w>- J:
1-< l)
~a. en
Iii -
"0 0
b 0 W
- ra I- 0 I-
<( 3: 2 <
-l <( - 0
::J 00 Cf.lol >-
:2 Cf.l-
0:: t() w<( <
0 c:: ....Ie.. a.
0
u., ..... -.:t
>- Iii N
W W ....II- 'F'
...
Cf.l w <z to
Cf.l ..... to
c: 00 1-3:
<( - t()
:2 "4- en Ow I
- 0 N I-z I
c 'r' ,
2 0 -
0 +: ~ l-ot()U)O 0> ~
l- ra Ww 00 20~~o 0 co
<( ::l ~I- m -..qo'r''F''F' ~ l.O
....I {) ~<( ....I to en .~ 'F' .t--
::J Iii <( ",-
~ Iii wO:: l-
t) I.) ~ >1- 0
....I W
<( 0:: t) <(2 l-
t) N ..qoOON N
I- M 000<"1 M
cn cn Ln cnl'-NN'F' 10
W u.,J: N J: 'r''''- N
0:: o!z I-
W Z
I- 00 0
2 2:2: :2:
-....."..~
'F W
'N: M I-
<(
S:!:> 0 0::
to
O".d1. N Ln I-
~:~'$ >- ..qo C/)
all ill
i i~::tg > 0::
w
U;;::~.:N: 0 I-
- Z
'F'
@ W
0 (!)
~ 0 N ....l <
W C) 'F'
0:: C'i <C n::
~ 0 I- "'-NM~ I- W
<(zo:: W O':JO'.!O'.!O'.! 0 >
O'JO'.!O":;O'.!
zenCL, 0:: "II"'" 'F' ",- ",- I- <(
-".- .......-----..... ,.,.,.,....."""""""".."~~_.............--.~"""""~-...............
.... ...............
-~
M
l-W 'F
U)...J 'F
Woo ~
0::< It'J
W> ~
1-< U
~~ U)
In 0
1:: 0 W
- ~ l- 0 l-
<C ...... z <
...J ~ - C
~ 00 ~O ~
~ It'J w<C <
~ C..J~ ~
o 0 ---.--....
u.. ..... M
>- In 'F
Q,}
W b ,I- 'F
U) Q,} _. ~
U) ..... <C Z L.'":J
<C C ~ IiI- s:
:E "0 m ;;~ W
-- ~ z
z C 'F . ___..
o
o .- 'F I- 0 It'J It'J 0 0 'F
~ ro Will ~ ZO~~O 0 m
<( ~ ~~ ~ -~'F'F'F N ~
..J 0 <(<( ..J m~'F 00
:J m In ~a:: < 'F
t) 0 ~ w~ ~
..J Q,} >z 0
<( 0:: t) <_ l-
t) ~ NOON ~
I- . M OOOM M
U) U) ~ U)'FNN'F ~
W u..~ ~ ~ 'F'F N
0:: 01- I-
W Z Z
I- 00 0
Z z.~ ~
--...."""........-
00 W
-.001-
-. <
N.... ~ _
N ~ ~
.).. ~ It'J L-
.... N. . M r-
:C" 00;; >- U)
G~~ 00 ill
~A~ > 0::
:>i.W':W. ;:;: ill
.u;,.~'(N bl _._........ I-
L.':J Z
~ W
~ ~ G
ill G 0 'F -J <(
~ 0 ~ ~ 'F~M~ ~ ill
.....Z~ W mmmm 0 >
~-~ mmmm
ZU)~ 0:: ~'F'F~ ~ <(
..........""...... . ............--.............................~_.....~-.......,.__...._.. ..........- ""...""""..
,
~
~
~.
I
0
I-UJ M
(/)...J ll'l
Woo ll'l
0::<( ~
W> J:
1-< U
~Q. 00
!/;! -.....""..'-
"0 0
t- O LU
...- ~ I- 0 I-
< 3: z <(
...J < - 0
:J ~ (/)0
:E m (1)- >-
a;: W<I: <I:
0 c ......!Q. 0..
0 ...~h__........'.,,,.,,.."""..,.
u.. ..... 0
>- lfl M
W C\,l ...JI- m
t-
CI) C\,l m
CI) - <~ C';l
< c 00 I-s:
- ll'l
:E - ~ Ow
'-" 0 N I-Z
Z C <r"
0 0 """".0;,
+:i Ww i(4 I-ll'l ll'.lll'.l 0 to M
~ \'\3 m Zl"-I'-NO I"- m
- ~ 1-.
:l I"- -M'l*"''l*'''~ l- t--
...J tJ 0::< ...JI"-~r-~ "d'
:::l - u:J <.( N
\'\3 u:J wO::
U tJ ~ >1- I-
..J Q,) - 0
<( 0:: () <.(~ I-
(J -- .~~
I- 01 I'-OON en
co (l)ll'lOOM ro
(I) (I) N
W :t:1 ::cI'-NN'r
0:: u,,1- M I- ~'r
W Oz Z
I- 00 0
z z:E :E
-
-..........-
I (0 W
I 0 ~
I I'-
N N 0:::
(0
>- "d' I-
(I)
CO W
> 0::
0 W
-...~ l-
N Z
'l*'" W
~ ~ 0
0 m
W G N ...J ~
a:;. aJ <(
::2:z0 I- 'rNM~ I- W
W O)~O'Jm
<_0::: C}O)O'JO'l 0 >
zooQ. 0:: 'r'r''l*''''r I- <.(,
_......__-L-.....-..... .......__._.._..._.....M.........._~
I
to
I-w l'
U).J co I
Wco l'
;0: <( co
W :t:
1->-
z<( U
_0.. 00
in ......-.............."""""""-..'.
"0 0
.... 0 w
,- fa I-
<( 3: 0 ~
z ,
.J <( -
:J 00 IE ~ 0
:E to >-
0: <(
0 C .J 0.. ~"""""__~_" 0.
0
u.. .....
>- in
W Qj co
.... ..JiI-
(/) ! l'
{/) C 00 <(~ 00
<( .- to 1-3:
:E "l- 0) Ow
- 0 N I-z
Z r" 'F'
0 ...~""""
0 ~
~ !('; il-O to\lf'\ 0 0 to
..- Ww M
~ ~ ZOl'~O 0 ('1
::l (;)1- t- -"'-t'F'''l'"''''l'"'' to l'
.J <) ~<( .Jt.OO'lt-'t'"" (")
::J - in <( N
fa wOC
t) 0 in I-
.J Cl> ~ >1- 0
<( OC () <t:Z l-
t) I -..----
l- :,0 "'-tOON to
(/) m ~ mOOOM M
I W u..:t: N :t:t-NN'F' N
I OC \:'; l-'F'''l'"'' (")
11..1 O~ Z
I- 00 0
Z z :E 1_ :E
-
-
1.;"\ W
l"- I-
0 <(
N M IX
~
>- ~ I-
OCI U)
W
> OC
0 w
...""".~~ I-
O'l Z
~ --
'F' W
* 0 :,0 (,9
Ul (!j ro ..J <(
::E 0 0:: to <C ex:
I- .,,-N(")~
<(~a: W mO'io>m l- W
i O'lO'icnm 0 >
2000.. ex: i
.__~........li~ I __ i _.~..~-.:::_ "l'"" l- <(
""~............._~.~...................~-"",~~__..,.,.,.,c_~____""""
--- ............_..............,~- . - ........--~..................
~
.................
LO
I-W co
CI.l..J "'"
WOCl N
0:<( LO
I W>- :t:
1-<( U
~o.. U)
in ---....................""""""'" .
"'C 10
I.. 0 W
- rn I-
3: 10 I-
<C Z <C
..J <C
:J 00 CI.lO 0
:2; lO CI.l- >-
a: W< <(
0 c: ....Jo. 0.
0 ~--'..
U. '01-' lO
>- in 00
W 1D
1- ....JI- "'"
U) 1D <(z N
U) ..... to
C 00
<( - lO 1-;:
:2; "l- O'l Ow
--- 0 N I-Z
Z c: 't'""
0 0
01-' 'r" I-OlOtnO 0 'r"
~ ell> Ww O'l ZCt-~O 10 0)
::l (91- tt:J -oo"l'""'r"'r" N tt:J
....J 0 ~~ ....J 01t-'t'"" ro
:J rn in <( 't'""
U 0 in WI- I-
.J 1D ell> >z 0
<C a: u <- I-
U -
I- ~ NOON ~
U) CI.l M CI.lOOC~ M
W u..J: tt:J :t:"l'""NN'r" to
a: N I- 't'""'t'"" N
W O~ Z
I- 00 0
z z:E :E
_....~
M W
(:I M I-
;~ 10 ~
N 00
~
~:::~:.~. >- M l-
OCI U)
W
> a::
:E'OO .00, c w
'.,'iq N.
_..~ I-
tn Z
to W
10
:t:t 0 to (,9
W C) O'l ....J <(
::2EZO 0:: to <C c:::
I- 'r N ('') ~ I- W
<_a: W m01O':lO':l
ZOOo.. 0: O1mO':lm 0 >
l "l'"" 'F' 'r' ''I'"'' I- <(
..- ....----"""" ..........""'...................--~_."""
.....---..~". """......
r----' .. ..""'-""'" --........................
-. r-' '
Ii
.............;S
t-
I-w al
en..J 0
Woo M
0:<( 0)
w> J:
1-<( U
~o. 00
f/.; -
"'C 0
I- 10 W
- rn I- 10 ~
<( 3: z
-1 <( .- 0
; :J eno
I 00 >
:E en-
1.0 w<( <(
a: c -10. 0.
0 0 ..~_....................,.
u. .... l'
>- f/.; al
W cu -11- 10
1-
en Qj <(~ M
U) ..... m
c 00 1-:;:
<( -- tn
:2; "l- m Ow
........ 0 N I-Z
Z C 'F'
0 ."""""""""~ -......,.-,
0 1>; Ww 0) I-tntOtOo tn 0)
I- m ~ Zt-t-~C t- "'-t
<( ::l ~I- ~ - M 'r 'r' 'F' t- l'
....Ii 0 ~~ ....t-O)t-'r' ~
:J - Iii <t: N
ro
U 0 Iii WI- 1-'
ro 0,
....Ii 1D - >z
<C a: U <C- I- L-,
U 00 tOOON ro
I- 0 t-OO{'1 0
en CI) M Ult-NN'F' M
W u..J: M :t:, 'r' 'r' M
0: O~ I-
W Z
I- 00 0
z z:E :2.
--
tt:J W
~':~ N I-
0) <(
N 10 0:
to l- I
:t::.. '~ >- ~ I
01''''''' .' CI) ,
NutQ . a.. CO w
~<~~... > a::
0 w
:E'~N I-
Z
'r'
to W
00 C)
=lit 0 'F' ,<(
W C) 10
~ en 0:::
::EzO I- ~N{'1~ W
W malcrlO'll :>
<(_0::: crlO)mO'll
ZWQ. 0: 'F 'r' 'f'" 'r <(
.~_......-.__...............-......
_.---.-1-.-"-- _......_"-.."".---~_.
~
:,0
I-W aa
tn.J N
,~ co M
i <( 0)
\W >- ::t:
,I- <( U
IZ (1)
_0..
f/.; ---
"'C 0
I- 0 W
- (I:l I- 0 I-
<C ~ .Z <(
..J - 0
:::l (0 (1)0 >-
:IE en-
D::: 'Jl:) w<( <(
c ....10. 0.
0 0 .._n'''~~~
u.. ..... w
>- f/.; 0)
\ w Q) .JI- N
l-
V) Cl> <(~ M
(/ll ..... en
c (0 r-s:
<C - lO
:IE ..... Cl:l Ow
I 0
i -' N r-Z
Z .... "l'""
0 ________.J,\. '"~
0 ~ M F' to lO !.O 0 to M
...... ~ UJw LO Z""'t-~o "'" to
';i - (1).1- t- -. M"l'"" "l'"" '\:"'" "'" "'"
::l
.....1 0 <C<( _J""'Cl:lt-'\:"'" "d'
'::;) {ij m a:ct <t: N
U 0 f/.; WI- F'
~ 0
i ..J W - >Z
<( 0:: U <- I- .._...1
U N oOON N
I- Cl:l IDOOM m
en 00 N (f;l ~ N N 'F' N
W :t: M :t: "l'""'r' M
\ a: u..1- 1-'
W Oz 2:
I- O~ 0
Z 'Z ,:2:
-~-
"'" UJ
oq I-
<(
co 0::
N 'F'
LO r-
<0;,; ,... "d' en
.'~. lOCI UJ
~', 2: 0:
.~ 0 UJ
N: I-
."".--- Z
M \
t- W
~ l' C)
0 M ~ i
W C) 0 ....I
0:: en <(
:2 0 I- ,>' ~ M "'it I- W
\ <~a:: w 01> 0'> en en 0 :;(
01>0'>0)0)
zeno.. 0:: 'F't'""'F''F' I-
---.-----------......-----......--..........-----.--.--
~""""... -' "".""""..,,,,. 1""""""..--
!
,-
10
I-w (,C
~..J 00
t-
0::00 N
W<( :t:
1->-
Z<( U
.....0.. en
m
"C e
1- 10 W
- ro l- e I-
<( 3: z <(
.J <C - CI
:J 00 UJo >-
:E UJ-
to w<( <C
0:: ,... ..Jo.. 0..
0 ....
0 ...., H'
u.. "'" 0
)- in to
W CU ..JI- 00
I..
UJ CU <C~ I"-
en "'" N
<( C 00 1-3:
to
:2E - 0) Ow
- 0 N I-Z
Z C 'r"
0 -~
0 M tntOO e M
;: ww :,0 l-NNO to tt:J
I- (tI Z .
<( ::l (;)1- :,0 -(JO~~ 00 to
..J 0 ~<( ..J~t-"l'"" N
:J i(I) (( ~
fa in wO:: l-
t.) u ('i$ >1- 0
..J CU -
<( 0:: U <(~ I-
U _.""."""""".~
t- l.f')CN l"-
I- M OOM M
en (Jj cri (Jj~N't'"" m
W u..:t: '!""" :I: '!""" ~
0: O~ I-
W Z
I- 00 0
Z z:S :s
0) w
$:., .~ to I-
<(
1::f.N 'r 0::
o:~: N 0>
{;O I-
~~: ,'Q; >- N en
. ,,'N,C'? CO W
]t~ ~' :> 0::
0 W
en~.,~" I-
...........--...."""""- Z
to
M W
M C)
:;t 0>
W Cl 0 N ~ ..J <(
0:: 1.0 ~ 0::
:! 0 I- NM~ I- W
<(~o:: W mO')O) 0 :>
crimm
zen 0.. .0::: 'F't'""'F' I- <C
...............,....-.-~... ........< ............... fi ...........'..",.,.,,~.~..~--..,'_......,..,~
'F'
;;<1
~
;;<1
l.O
:r.
()
ffJ
IJl
"0 .0
:;... .0 UJ
;( (t\ 0 ~
~
.J 0
::'.) ()(') ~
ti l.O .::t
c 0.-
0 0
u... ""'" 'F'
(ij IJl (")
Qj
I..
(/) Qj
(/) .....
c tf:)
<{ - 1.0
~ a C'i
N
:z c 'I:'"'"
0
0 ~ ~ \-01.0;0.0 0
- C'i ZOl-~.o .0
l;;i - ~ _tf:)'t"''I:'"'"'I:'"'" N {.O
:.:i
.J <) <i C'il-~ I:tJ
:::J "@ IJl ~
IJl \-
0 0 (t\
;i ~ - 0
t) \-
0 ~ N
""'" ;;<1 en ("'1\
(/) 0 ~ 0
uJ N :t: N
tt. \-
Ul Z
~ 0
~
-
~ oJ
"!"" ~
'"
t-
en
I.U
"
UJ
t-
I:tJ Z
-
N
# 0
.0
uJ C) .0
~ 0 t-
<(~o:'.
..~ ~^ n
:r::
u
1J)
t$)
"t.',}
"'"
I't1
3-
&.
(lO
to
,~
t$)
w Qj ~
"" O':l
il) t.O
1J) ~ (lO a
~ to to a
.- ~ \- t- ~
~ '0 ~ -;cO~~~
<f
Ij) N ('1
in ('1 t.O
{\\. ~ N
.-
U
uJ
'to ~
Ul t'!.
ct ~
uJ
'i ~
- uJ
!Z.
.....
~
uJ f!)
~ ~
fi.
- -.. ......... """'-~................-'
F -----. --,
I
-
'I""
I-W t-
en-l ~
Woo M
0:<( l('l
W>- J:
1-<( U
~o.. tn
f/.; -
"0 0
I- 0 W
...- ell> I- 0 I-
<( 3: z <(
..J <( ..... C
:::J 00 enc >-
:a: (1)-
I.fJ W<( <C
IX: c ..Jo.. 0..
0 0 ,~'"
u.. ..... ''I''''
>- W ~
W cu ..JI- ~
:k
<n Cl> <(~ M
<n ..... lfi
<( C 00 1-;;:
- to
:a: ..... 0) Ow
- 0 N I-z
Z C 'F'
0 --........ ............,
0 :;:; 'F' I-CLnlOO; 0; "l'""
- Ww O':l 0 C':i
I- fa ZCt-~O;
<( ::l (;)1- {O - ro 'F' 'F' ~ N tt:J
-l <) <<( -l mt-~ ro
::> w O:::e::: <C 'IF
(tl
() U in WI- I-
(tl 0
-l cu - >z
<( e::: u <(- I- ---'
() .....""""-~
"t NOON ~
I- M eOOM M
{J) tn {O ~~NN'r (0
W :t: N N
u..1- ''r' ~
0: 1--
W Oz Z
I- 00 0
z z:E :2
-
tn W
1,f} I-
\0 <(
N N a::
tn I-
.s::i;; >- M en
':t'?:: co W
r :> 0::
to. 0 W
iN: I-
..............-..., Z
0 ~
't'"" W
# 'F' t)
lt1
W C) 0 0 -l ~
0: t- -<<
::;:ZO I- ~NM~ I- W
C;lmOiOi
<(~O:: W C;lOiOim 0 >
ZtnCL e::: 'I"" ~ 'IF 'F' I- <C
-....... .... """."""""~...._..........~-"""""""..""~-~..............................~........._....,.,.....,