HomeMy WebLinkAbout2007-1104.Goring.08-07-08 Decision
Commission de
Crown Employees
Grievance Settlement
règlement des griefs
Board
des employés de la
Couronne
Suite 600 Bureau 600
180 Dundas St. West 180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8 Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388 Tél. : (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396 Téléc. : (416) 326-1396
GSB# 2007-1104 and files listed in Appendix A
UNION# 2007-0517-0087 and files listed in Appendix A
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Goring)
Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services)
Employer
BEFOREVice-Chair
Deborah J.D. Leighton
FOR THE UNION Scott Andrews
Grievance Officer
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
FOR THE EMPLOYER Brian Scott
Staff Relations Officer
Ministry of Community Safety and
Correctional Services
HEARING
July 7, 2008.
2
Decision
Ms. Wendy Goring has sixty-eight grievances before the board. Eight of those are competition
grievances. Of the competition grievances, the union and the grievor have decided to focus on
what the grievor considers to be the most egregious. At the outset of the hearing scheduled for
mediation-arbitration, pursuant to Article 22.16 of the collective agreement between the parties,
the union requested the production of documents for two of the competitions being grieved by
Ms. Goring. The first is for a permanent Probation and Parole Officer in Oakville, the second
for a position in Don Mills. The employer had concerns about the privacy of the applicants in
these competitions.
I made an order at the hearing as follows:
The documents produced by the employer on July 7, 2008 of the Oakville competition
file, with the names of the applicants redacted, and any and all further documents
forwarded to the union with regard to Ms. Goring?s grievances, made pursuant to the
disclosure request by the union shall not be used for any other purpose and only for this
grievance.
The parties also agreed to an expedited hearing process with regard to the grievances before me,
which is now hereby ordered by the board:
1.The employer shall forward the documents for the Don Mills competition (June 2007) to
the union with the names of the applicants redacted, by July 21,2008;
2.The union has until July 28, 2008 to inform the employer if documents are missing;
3.The employer has five working days to respond to any additional request for documents
by the union;
4.The union shall forward its written submissions and any case law that it relies on to the
board by 5 pm on August 11, 2008.
5.The employer shall forward its written submission and any case law that it relies on to the
board by 5 pm on September 8, 2008.
3
6.Should any issues arise between the parties regarding the time limits noted above, the
board should be notified immediately, and the problem shall be heard by conference call.
7.Upon receipt of the parties? submissions, the board shall issue a written decision.
th
Dated at Toronto this 8 day of July, 2008.
D.J.D. Leighton, Vice Chair
4
Appendix A
Grievances of Wendy Goring
GSB# OPSEU#
2007-1104 2007-0517-0087
2007-1105 2007-0517-0088
2007-1300 2007-0517-0089
2007-1301 2007-0517-0090
2007-1302 2007-0517-0091
2007-1303 2007-0517-0092
2007-1304 2007-0517-0093
2007-1305 2007-0517-0094
2007-1306 2007-0517-0095
2007-2702 2007-0517-0130
2007-2703 2007-0517-0131
2007-3399 2007-0517-0192
2007-3400 2007-0517-0193
2007-3401 2007-0517-0194
2007-3402 2007-0517-0195
2007-3403 2007-0517-0196
2007-3404 2007-0517-0197
2007-3405 2007-0517-0198
2007-3406 2007-0517-0199
2007-3407 2007-0517-0200
2007-3408 2007-0517-0201
2007-3409 2007-0517-0202
2007-3410 2007-0517-0203
2007-3411 2007-0517-0204
2007-3412 2007-0517-0205
2007-3413 2007-0517-0206
2007-3414 2007-0517-0207
2007-3415 2007-0517-0208
2007-3416 2007-0517-0209
2007-3417 2007-0517-0210
2007-3418 2007-0517-0211
2007-3419 2007-0517-0212
2007-3420 2007-0517-0213
2007-3421 2007-0517-0214
2007-3422 2007-0517-0215
2007-3423 2007-0517-0216
2007-3424 2007-0517-0217
2007-3425 2007-0517-0218
2007-3426 2007-0517-0219
2007-3427 2007-0517-0220
5
GSB# OPSEU#
2007-3428 2007-0517-0221
2007-3429 2007-0517-0222
2007-3430 2007-0517-0223
2007-3431 2007-0517-0224
2007-3432 2007-0517-0225
2007-3433 2007-0517-0226
2007-3434 2007-0517-0227
2007-3435 2007-0517-0228
2007-3436 2007-0517-0229
2007-3437 2007-0517-0230
2007-3438 2007-0517-0231
2007-3439 2007-0517-0232
2007-3440 2007-0517-0233
2007-3441 2007-0517-0234
2007-3442 2007-0517-0235
2007-3443 2007-0517-0236
2007-3444 2007-0517-0237
2007-3445 2007-0517-0238
2007-3446 2007-0517-0239
2007-3447 2007-0517-0240
2007-3448 2007-0517-0241
2007-3449 2007-0517-0242
2007-3450 2007-0517-0243
2007-3487 2008-0517-0016
2007-3488 2008-0517-0017
2007-3489 2008-0517-0018
2007-3490 2008-0517-0019
2007-3491 2008-0517-0020