HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-0144.Adamiec et al.20-11-03 DecisionCrown Employees
Grievance
Settlement Board
Suite 600
180 Dundas St. West
Toronto, Ontario M5G
1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396
Commission de
règlement des
griefs
des employés de la
Couronne
Bureau 600
180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto (Ontario) M5G
1Z8
Tél. : (416) 326-1388
Téléc. : (416) 326-1396
GSB# 2019-0144
UNION# 2019-0248-0010
Full list of files attached in “Appendix A”
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Adamiec et al) Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of the Solicitor General) Employer
BEFORE
Brian P. Sheehan
Arbitrator
FOR THE UNION
Gregg Gray
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
Grievance Officer
FOR THE
EMPLOYER
James Cheng
Treasury Board Secretariat
Employee Relations Advisor
HEARING August 26, 2020 (by videoconference)
-2-
DECISION
[1] In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb
process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was agreed that overtime
grievances would be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the
stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely manner
to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each institution.
Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped that these
monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances.
[2] It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to deal
exclusively with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would meet to
attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining disputes would be
put before this Board.
[3] In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the
parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. Since that time a
number of sessions have been held and various decisions rendered. The process
has not been altered and continues to serve the parties well.
[4] The grievances determined herein were dealt with on August 26, 2020.
[5] Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and made submissions regarding
the various disputes. Attached as Appendix A is the list of grievances and the
disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors as set out
in the attached appendix are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate less statutory
deductions.
[6] I remain seized.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 3rd day of November, 2020.
“Brian P. Sheehan”
_____________________
Brian P. Sheehan, Arbitrator
-3-
Appendix A
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
Adamiec, Rafal 2019-0248-0010 2019-0144 03/06/2019
Upheld - 12 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Bin Othman, Ahmed 2019-0248-0011 2019-0145 03/06/2019 Upheld - 4 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Schroeder, Ryan 2019-0248-0012 2019-0146 03/07/2019 Upheld - 4 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Warne, Edward 2019-0248-0013 2019-0147 03/06/2019 Dismissed
Coudenys, Michael 2019-0248-0014 2019-0148 03/06/2019 Upheld - 4 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Doner, Clayton 2019-0248-0015 2019-0149 03/06/2019 Upheld - 4 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Anttila, Kari et al 2019-0248-0004 2019-0138 03/07/2019 Dismissed
Scriven, Robert 2019-0248-0005 2019-0139 03/06/2019 Upheld - 12 hours OT
Malcolmson, Gregg 2019-0248-0006 2019-0140 03/06/2019 Upheld - 12 hours OT
Champagne, Nicole 2019-0248-0007 2019-0141 03/06/2019 Upheld - 12 hours OT
Devries, Melissa 2019-0248-0008 2019-0142 03/07/2019 Upheld - 8 hours OT
Pinder, Christopher 2019-0248-0009 2019-0143 03/07/2019 Upheld - 12 hours OT
Alkazely, Saleh 2017-0248-0018 2017-0485 04/22/2017 Dismissed
Brearley, Craig 2017-0248-0197 2017-2463 10/25/2017 Upheld - 12 hours OT
De Freitas, Ricky 2017-0248-0165 2017-2114 10/02/2017 Upheld - 12 hours OT
Devries, Melissa 2017-0248-0016 2017-0409 04/15/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0017 2017-0410 04/15/2017 Upheld in part – 8 hours OT
2017-0248-0190 2017-2387 10/08/2017 Upheld – 16 hours OT
2017-0248-0191 2017-2388 10/08/2017 Upheld – 16 hours OT
Dowling, Christopher 2017-0248-0185 2017-2134 10/02/2017 Dismissed
Escoto, Tayron 2016-0248-0040 2016-2167 11/08/2016 Upheld – 8 hours at straight
time
Giovannangeli,
Roberto
2017-0248-0008 2016-2763 02/10/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0006 2016-2761 02/21/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0003 2016-2566 01/24/2017 Dismissed
2016-0248-0041 2016-2245 12/16/2016 Dismissed
2016-0248-0033 2016-2070 11/24/2016 Dismissed
Heiliger, David 2016-0248-0034 2016-2071 11/24/2016 Upheld in part – 8 hours OT
2013-0248-0027 2013-2569 06/20/2013 Upheld – 8 hours OT
Jacobson, Steve 2016-0248-0009 2016-0465 04/29/2016 Dismissed
Lane, Trevor 2017-0248-0132 2017-1972 09/26/2017 Upheld – 12 hours OT
Leroux, Tim 2017-0248-0085 2017-1816 09/05/2017 Dismissed
-4-
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
MacDonald, Shaun 2016-0248-0029 2016-1913 11/11/2016 Upheld – 12 hours OT
McIlveen, Lynn 2017-0248-0009 2016-2764 02/10/2017 Dismissed
Muth, Peter 2016-0248-0035 2016-2072 11/23/2016 Dismissed
Neville, Kayne 2018-0248-0115 2018-0094 02/08/2018 Upheld - 4 hours at straight
time; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
Pracey, Tammy 2017-0248-0055 2017-1628 07/10/2017 Dismissed
Stathakos, Vrasidas 2017-0248-0146 2017-2044 10/02/2017 Dismissed
Tatryn, Todd 2017-0248-0193 2017-2446 10/25/2017 Dismissed
Al-Jalili, Ali 2017-0248-0046 2017-1443 07/29/2017 Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison 2017-0248-0180 2017-2129 10/02/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0181 2017-2130 10/02/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0107 2017-1853 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0081 2017-1812 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0064 2017-1770 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0065 2017-1771 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0066 2017-1772 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Borsatto, Sergio 2017-0248-0140 2017-1980 09/26/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0087 2017-1818 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Brearley, Craig 2017-0248-0351 2017-3122 12/06/2017 Dismissed
Champagne, Nicole 2018-0248-0023 2017-3650 01/13/2018 Allowed – 12 hours OT
2017-0248-0024 2017-1097 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Collins, Elizabeth 2017-0248-0031 2017-1262 06/30/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0025 2017-1098 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Creighton, Robert 2017-0248-0166 2017-2115 10/02/2017 Dismissed
Devries, Melissa 2017-0248-0239 2017-2621 10/08/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0223 2017-2515 10/25/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0192 2017-2389 10/08/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0189 2017-2386 10/08/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0111 2017-1857 09/05/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0015 2017-0408 04/15/2017 Dismissed
Edwards, Michael 2017-0248-0120 2017-1866 09/26/2017 Dismissed
Heiliger, David 2017-0248-0071 2017-1777 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Iacoviello, Paul 2017-0248-0032 2017-1395 07/25/2017 Dismissed
Jovic, Marko 2017-0248-0121 2017-1867 09/26/2017 Dismissed
Kearns, Steven 2017-0248-0023 2017-1096 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Kennedy, Kevin 2017-0248-0252 2017-2683 11/07/2017 Dismissed
Masson, Paul 2017-0248-0036 2017-1433 07/29/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0028 2017-1259 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Masson, Derek 2016-0248-0013 2016-0705 05/27/2016 Dismissed
McIlveen, Lynn 2017-0248-0225 2017-2517 10/25/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0063 2017-1769 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Mesaric, Sean 2017-0248-0029 2017-1260 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Penic, Michael 2017-0248-0026 2017-1238 06/30/2017 Dismissed
Pinder, Christopher 2017-0248-0322 2017-3077 12/06/2017 Allowed – 12 hours OT
-5-
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
Moniz, Colin 2013-0234-0340 2013-2857 10/31/2013 Dismissed
Ranck, Kelly 2013-0234-0351 2013-3168 11/11/2013 Upheld – 12 hours STAT
(double time)
Noble, Earle 2011-0234-0062 2011-0764 05/09/2011 Dismissed
2014-0234-0415 2014-3028 07/30/2014 Upheld – 12 hours OT
Pinneau, Wayne 2009-0582-0104 2009-1770 08/10/2009 Dismissed
2009-0582-0105 2009-1771 08/10/2009 Dismissed
Pinkney, Suzanne 2013-0108-0064 2013-1111 06/07/2013 Dismissed
Alaimo, Vince 2012-0248-0016 2012-0406 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison 2012-0248-0017 2012-0407 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Brearley, Craig 2012-0248-0018 2012-0408 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Buttenham, Brian 2012-0248-0019 2012-0409 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Devries, Melissa 2012-0248-0020 2012-0410 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Graham, Patricia 2012-0248-0021 2012-0411 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Gulka, Patrick 2012-0248-0022 2012-0412 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Jackson, Dennis 2012-0248-0023 2012-0413 03/06/2012 Dismissed
MacNeil, Laurie 2012-0248-0024 2012-0414 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Millen, Darcy 2012-0248-0026 2012-0416 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Sebele, Michele 2012-0248-0027 2012-0417 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Siguenza, William 2012-0248-0028 2012-0418 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Stavropoulos, Angela 2012-0248-0029 2012-0419 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Walker, Paul 2012-0248-0030 2012-0420 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Whyte, Thomas 2012-0248-0031 2012-0421 03/03/2012 Dismissed
Zizzo, Christopher 2012-0248-0032 2012-0422 03/03/2012 Dismissed
Alaimo, Vince 2012-0248-0034 2012-0268 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison 2012-0248-0035 2012-0269 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Brearley, Craig 2012-0248-0036 2012-0270 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Buttenham, Brian 2012-0248-0037 2012-0271 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Devries, Melissa 2012-0248-0038 2012-0272 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Graham, Patricia 2012-0248-0039 2012-0273 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Gulka, Patrick 2012-0248-0040 2012-0274 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Jackson, Dennis 2012-0248-0041 2012-0275 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
Pollard, Philip 2009-0248-0043 2009-1954 09/29/2009 Allowed – 12 hours OT
Powell, David 2017-0248-0226 2017-2518 10/25/2017 Dismissed
Rodriguez, Walter 2017-0248-0104 2017-1835 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Shires, Bill 2017-0248-0061 2017-1767 09/19/2017 Dismissed
Spencer, Jason 2017-0248-0177 2017-2126 10/02/2017 Dismissed
Stathakos, Vrasidas 2017-0248-0187 2017-2136 10/02/2017 Dismissed
Tatryn, Todd 2017-0248-0109 2017-1855 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0108 2017-1854 09/19/2017 Dismissed
2016-0248-0025 2016-1601 09/13/2016 Dismissed
Jacobson, Steve 2017-0248-0172 2017-2121 10/02/2017 Dismissed
2017-0248-0147 2017-2045 10/02/2017 Dismissed
-6-
Maclean, Joyce 2012-0248-0043 2012-0277 03/05/2012 Dismissed
MacNeil, Laurie 2012-0248-0044 2012-0278 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Millen, Darcy 2012-0248-0046 2012-0280 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Saul, Lita 2012-0248-0047 2012-0281 03/08/2012 Dismissed
Sebele, Michele 2012-0248-0048 2012-0282 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Siguenza, William 2012-0248-0049 2012-0283 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Stavropoulos, Angela 2012-0248-0050 2012-0284 03/06/2012 Dismissed
Walker, Paul 2012-0248-0051 2012-0285 03/05/2012 Dismissed
Whyte, Thomas 2012-0248-0052 2012-0286 03/03/2012 Dismissed
Decambra, Jeffrey 2012-0582-0121 2012-0485 03/22/2012 Dismissed
Peacock, Daryl 2010-0582-0037 2010-1879 08/09/2010 Upheld – 12 hours OT
Brown, Linda 2009-0582-0095 2009-1777 10-Sep-09 Dismissed
Walterhouse,
Christopher
2009-0582-0099 2009-1763 23-Jul-09 Dismissed
Grievor OPSEU # GSB # Grievance Date Outcome
Manna, Mark et al 2017-5112-0245 2017-2305 09/05/2017 Upheld – 8 hours OT to each
grievor
Deyell, Robert 2007-0108-0036 2007-1381 07/25/2007 Dismissed
2007-0108-0037 2007-1382 07/25/2007 Dismissed
2008-0108-0083 2008-0520 04/29/2008 Upheld in Part – 8 hours OT
2008-0108-0099 2008-1138 06/14/2008 Upheld – 11 hours OT
2008-0108-0143 2008-3240 12/10/2008 Dismissed
2009-0108-0014 2008-4038 01/30/2009 Dismissed
2009-0108-0016 2008-4039 01/30/2009 Dismissed
2008-0108-0031 2007-3998 02/13/2008 Dismissed
2008-0108-0142 2008-3239 12/10/2008 Dismissed
2009-0108-0045 2009-1082 05/01/2009 Allowed – 7 hours OT
Guevarra, Krizzane 2015-5112-0231 2015-2610 11/14/2015 Allowed – 28 hours OT
Preyma, Mark 2018-5112-0149 2018-2191 09/05/2018 Allowed – 10 hours OT
2018-5112-0215 2018-3245 12/07/2018 Dismissed
Samuels, Jacqueline 2014-5112-0230 2014-3757 02/21/2014 Allowed – 12 hours straight
time
Sunmola, Margaret 2015-5112-0223 2015-2602 11/24/2015 Dismissed
Walsh, James 2014-5112-0100 2014-2847 08/01/2014 Allowed – 48 hours OT
Zoldak, Jolanta 2018-5112-0207 2018-3106 11/15/2018 Dismissed