HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-2275.Creighton et al.21-09-29 DecisionCrown Employees
Grievance Settlement
Board
Suite 600
180 Dundas St. West
Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396
Commission de
règlement des griefs
des employés de la
Couronne
Bureau 600
180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tél. : (416) 326-1388
Téléc. : (416) 326-1396
GSB# 2019-2275
UNION# 2019-0248-0032
Additional files are attached in Appendix “A”
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Creighton et al) Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of the Solicitor General) Employer
BEFORE
Brian P. Sheehan
Arbitrator
FOR THE UNION
Gregg Gray
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
Grievance Officer
FOR THE EMPLOYER
Justin O’Gorman
Treasury Board Secretariat
Employee Relations Advisor
HEARING June 24, 2021
-2-
DECISION
[1] In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb
process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was agreed that overtime
grievances would be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the
stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely
manner to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each
institution. Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped
that these monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances.
[2] It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to
deal exclusively with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would
meet to attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining
disputes would be put before this Board.
[3] In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the
parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. Since that time a
number of sessions have been held and various decisions rendered. The process
has not been altered and continues to serve the parties well.
[4] The grievances determined herein were dealt with on June 24, 2021.
[5] Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and made submissions
regarding the various disputes. Attached as Appendix A is the list of grievances
and the disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors
as set out in the attached appendix are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate
less statutory deductions.
[6] I remain seized.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 29th day of September, 2021.
“Brian P. Sheehan”
_________________________
Brian P. Sheehan, Arbitrator
-3-
Schedule A
Last Name First Name OPSEU # GSB # Grievance
Date Outcome
Creighton Robert 2019-0248-0032 2019-2275 5-Dec-19 Dismissed
Warne Edward 2019-0248-0033 2019-2276 12-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Abu Qamar Abdul 2019-0248-0034 2019-2269 13-Dec-19 Dismissed
Castles (Defreitas) Kelly 2019-0248-0035 2019-2270 12-Dec-19 Dismissed
Champagne Nicole 2019-0248-0036 2019-2271 12-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Blatchley Peter 2019-0248-0037 2019-2272 13-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Parkin Scott 2019-0248-0038 2019-2547 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Warne Edward 2019-0248-0039 2019-2548 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Champagne Nicole 2019-0248-0040 2019-2549 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Champagne Nicole 2019-0248-0041 2019-2550 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Kennedy Kevin 2019-0248-0043 2019-2552 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Plouffe Pierre 2019-0248-0044 2019-2553 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Kendall Arissa 2019-0248-0045 2019-2554 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Vanderdeen Geoff 2019-0248-0046 2019-2555 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Benchina David 2019-0248-0047 2019-2556 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Fairchild Peter 2019-0248-0048 2019-2557 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Parkin Scott 2019-0248-0049 2019-2558 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Allan Curtis 2019-0248-0050 2019-2559 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Fairchild Peter 2019-0248-0051 2019-2560 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Fairchild Peter 2019-0248-0052 2019-2561 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Dasilva Rui 2019-0248-0053 2019-2562 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Parkin Scott 2019-0248-0054 2019-2599 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Nyaga Richard 2019-0248-0055 2019-2600 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Lusby Chris 2019-0248-0056 2019-2601 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Allan Curtis 2019-0248-0057 2019-2602 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Benchina David 2019-0248-0058 2019-2603 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Lusby Chris 2019-0248-0059 2019-2604 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Benchina David 2019-0248-0060 2019-2605 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Prelich Robert 2019-0248-0061 2019-2606 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Lusby Chris 2019-0248-0062 2019-2607 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Veland Christian 2019-0248-0063 2019-2608 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Devries Melissa 2019-0248-0064 2019-2609 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Abu Qamar Abdul 2019-0248-0065 2019-2610 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
-4-
Creighton Robert 2019-0248-0066 2019-2611 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Dasilva Rui 2019-0248-0067 2019-2612 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Go Joseph 2019-0248-0068 2019-2613 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Gould Jayce 2019-0248-0069 2019-2614 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Singh Daljinder 2019-0248-0070 2019-2615 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Stirling Joseph 2019-0248-0071 2019-2616 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Curtis Allan 2019-0248-0072 2019-2617 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Curtis Allan 2019-0248-0073 2019-2618 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Parkin Scott 2019-0248-0074 2019-2619 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Go Joseph 2019-0248-0075 2019-2620 4-Dec-19 Dismissed
Doyle Taylor 2019-0248-0076 2019-2621 4-Dec-19 Upheld - 2 Hours at
Straight Time
Easter Bradley 2019-0108-0036 2019-2665 18-Apr-19 Dismissed
Easter Bradley 2019-0108-0037 2019-2666 9-Mar-19 Dismissed
Greer-Taylor Sharon 2015-0108-0026 2015-1483 18-Jun-15 Dismissed
Matthew Mitchell 2019-0108-0022 2019-1612 17-Apr-19 Dismissed
Moyer Joanne 2018-0108-0028 2018-1841 14-May-18 Dismissed
James David 2017-0119-0021 2017-2100 4-Oct-17 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Koster Michael 2018-0119-0007 2018-1253 30-Apr-18 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Snieder Kevin 2017-0119-0011 2017-1394 25-Jul-17 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Snieder Kevin 2018-0119-0001 2017-3750 21-Feb-18 Dismissed
Mckay Shannon 2019-0369-0020 2019-0863 8-Feb-19 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Sutherland Steve 2020-0616-0029 2020-2230 2-Nov-20 Dismissed
Sutherland Steve 2020-0616-0030 2020-2231 23-Sep-20 Dismissed
White Steven 2020-0616-0035 2020-2314 14-Sep-20 Dismissed
White Steven 2020-0616-0036 2020-2315 16-Sep-20 Dismissed
Gulli Rina 2020-0678-0006 2020-1719 16-Aug-20 Dismissed
Gulli Rina 2020-0678-0007 2020-1768 23-Aug-20 Dismissed
Reville (Group) Theodore 2017-0678-0012 2018-1837 18-Dec-17 Dismissed
Reville (Group) Theodore 2018-0678-0007 2018-1565 18-Jun-18 Dismissed
Archer Glen 2018-0719-0010 2018-1439 3-Feb-18 Dismissed
Bailey Mark 2017-0719-0019 2017-1507 25-Apr-17 Dismissed
Faulds Robert 2015-0719-0033 2016-0528 30-May-15 Dismissed
Kerr Lori 2016-0719-0018 2016-1486 3-Oct-16 Dismissed
Kerr Lori 2016-0719-0019 2016-1487 6-Oct-16 Upheld - 8 Hours
Overtime
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0009 2017-1028 16-Apr-17 Dismissed
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0010 2017-1029 16-Apr-17 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0011 2017-1030 16-Apr-17 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0012 2017-1031 16-Apr-17 Dismissed
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0013 2017-1032 16-Apr-17 Dismissed
-5-
Kerr Lori 2017-0719-0018 2017-1037 7-Mar-17 Dismissed
McConomy David 2017-0719-0007 2017-0732 31-May-17 Dismissed
McConomy David 2018-0719-0009 2018-1438 16-Apr-18 Dismissed
Morgan Stewart 2017-0719-0005 2017-0184 24-Jan-17 Dismissed
Morgan Stewart 2017-0719-0015 2017-1034 24-Apr-17 Dismissed
Morgan Stewart 2017-0719-0016 2017-1035 27-Apr-17 Dismissed
Morgan Stewart 2018-0719-0011 2018-1440 16-Feb-18 Dismissed
Morgan Stewart 2018-0719-0025 2018-2968 25-Jun-18 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Morgan Stewart 2018-0719-0028 2019-0933 26-Dec-18 Dismissed
Olson Cindy 2018-0719-0013 2018-1442 14-May-18 Dismissed
Savage Curtis 2018-0719-0012 2018-1441 14-May-18 Dismissed
Sutherland Wade 2016-0719-0015 2016-1094 8-Aug-16 Dismissed
Sutherland Wade 2016-0719-0016 2016-1095 8-Aug-16 Dismissed
Johnston Jeffrey 2019-0229-0023 2019-1413 30-Jun-19 Dismissed
Parsons Michael 2019-0229-0030 2019-1761 26-Aug-19 Upheld - 12 Hours
Overtime
Ploedt Uwe 2020-0229-0215 2020-1563 4-Aug-20 Upheld - 2 Hours
Overtime
Webber Steven 2019-0229-0037 2019-1865 13-Sep-19 Dismissed
Zweigman Arthur 2020-0229-0060 2020-1321 14-Jul-20 Dismissed
Monto Shanna-Lee 2020-0737-0009 2020-0673 5-Feb-20 Dismissed
Aarnamo Jennifer 2012-0708-0014 2012-4715 20-Dec-12 Dismissed
Aarnamo Jennifer 2014-0708-0013 2014-3850 3-Nov-14 Dismissed
Aarnamo Jennifer 2014-0708-0016 2014-4575 6-Aug-14 Dismissed
Bouchard Sandy Rose 2013-0708-0017 2013-1622 11-Jun-13 Dismissed
Herron Andrew 2017-0708-0030 2017-3490 27-Nov-17 Dismissed
Hutchinson Bryan 2017-0708-0009 2017-1026 18-Apr-17 Dismissed
Kooistra Kelly 2014-0708-0002 2014-0050 24-Feb-14 Upheld - 10 Hours
Straight Time
Beetham Shane 2018-0582-0009 2017-4041 03-Jan-18 Upheld – 6 Hours OT
Blackstone Gregory 2018-0582-0030 2018-2677 08/27/2018 Dismissed
Bryant Matthew 2018-0582-0022 2018-0946 04/07/2018 Dismissed
Heaney Bruce 2018-0582-0007 2017-4039 01/18/2018 Dismissed
Thomas Mathew 2012-0582-0161 2012-1899 08/10/2012 Dismissed