HomeMy WebLinkAbout2005-1443.Tardiel et al.09-11-04 Decision
Commission de
Crown Employees
Grievance Settlement
règlement des griefs
Board
des employés de la
Couronne
Suite 600 Bureau 600
180 Dundas St. West 180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8 Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388 Tél. : (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396 Téléc. : (416) 326-1396
GSB#2005-1443
UNION#2005-0530-0022
Group ?A? & ?B?
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Tardiel et al)
Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
Employer
(Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services)
BEFOREChristopher J. Albertyn Vice-Chair
FOR THE UNIONDavid Wright, Ryder Wright Blair &
Holmes LLP, Barristers & Solicitors
Eric del Junco, Barrister and Solicitor
Donald McLeod, The McLeod Group,
Barristers and Solicitors
FOR THE EMPLOYERMelissa Nixon
Ministry of Government Services
Counsel
HEARINGOctober 28, 2009.
- 2 -
Decision
[1]There are several grievances in these matters that have the following similarity. They all
allege that the individual grievor concerned suffered harm and damages as a result of
working in a poisoned work environment, without reference to some other specific
triggering incident or event.I refer generically to these grievances as ?the poisoned work
environment grievances?.
[2]The only issue to be addressed in the poisoned work environment grievances is the
amount of money, if any, will be paid to each of the Grievors. Other systemic remedies
will be addressed in the Union?s policy grievance being addressed through the
organizational process described in previous decisions.
[3]The following protocol will apply to the hearing of the poisoned work environment
grievances.
1) The hearing of the Group B poisoned work environment grievances will take place on
April 6, 2010.
2) The hearing of the Group A poisoned work environment grievances will take place on
April 26, 2010.
3) The Union will be entitled to have 3 individuals present for each of the hearings,
pursuant to Article 22.11.1 of the parties? collective agreement.
4) At least 30 days prior to the hearing date, the Union will provide a group will-say
statement on which it intends to rely, with detail of its proposed monetary resolution.
5) At least 15 days prior to the hearing date, the Employer will provide a will-say
statement in response on which it intends to rely, with detail of its proposed monetary
resolution, if any.
6) At least 5 days prior to the hearing date, the Union may reply to the Employer?s
response.
7) In other respects, with the necessary alterations, the litigation protocol contained in
the Board?s decision of October 21, 2009 will apply.
th
Dated at Toronto this 4 day of November 2009.
Christopher J. Albertyn, Vice-Chair
Group A
GrievorGSB# Union File#
Tardiel, Charlene et al2005-14432005-0530-0022
Vasta, Al 2005-27022005-0530-0040
Henry, Herman 2005-38592005-0530-0052
Jauha, Kulwinder 2005-38602005-0530-0053
Miller, Frank 2005-38612005-0530-0054
Smith, Calvin 2005-38632005-0530-0056
McLennon, Michael 2005-38652005-0530-0058
Manor, Quincy 2005-38662005-0530-0059
Joseph, Manoj 2005-38672005-0530-0060
Lindo, Karen 2005-38692005-0530-0062
Cataline, Johnson 2005-38702005-0530-0063
LaRose, Colleen 2005-38712005-0530-0064
Harries-Jones, Sarah 2005-38742005-0530-0067
Gray, Veronica 2005-38752005-0530-0068
Grant, Caroline 2005-38762005-0530-0069
Ellis, Donovan 2005-38792005-0530-0072
Dawjee, Khalid 2005-38832005-0530-0076
Cox, Leroy 2005-38842005-0530-0077
Brewster, Mark2005-38862005-0530-0079
Alleyne, Perry 2005-38882005-0530-0081
Stewart-May, Patricia 2005-38892005-0530-0082
Samuels, Rhona 2005-38902005-0530-0083
Persaud, Bibi 2005-38912005-0530-0084
Ortiz, Florencio 2005-38932005-0530-0086
Olivierre, John 2005-38942005-0530-0087
Emmanuel, Mutema 2005-38952005-0530-0088
Moore, Mark 2005-38962005-0530-0089
Mohamed, Mohamed 2005-38982005-0530-0091
Thompson, Denise 2005-39012005-0530-0094
Cajamarca, John 2005-39092005-0530-0102
Tuan-Kiet, Doan 2005-39102005-0530-0103
Glover, Jason 2005-39122005-0530-0105
Montague, Roderick 2005-39172005-0530-0110
Tan, Joey 2005-39202005-0530-0113
Majid, Mohammad 2005-39222005-0530-0115
Skeffington, John 2005-39232005-0530-0116
Jackman, Marva 2006-01282006-0551-0002
Walcott, Pauline 2006-04222005-0530-0121
Marshall-Wilkinson, Joan2006-04232005-0530-0129
Walji, Nasim 2006-04242005-0530-0123
Joson, Nelson 2006-04252005-0530-0124
Manrique, Lolet 2006-04822005-0530-0125
Cajamarca, John 2006-06232006-0530-0019
Union2006-10792006-0530-0022
Vasta, Al 2006-11292005-0530-0126
Williams, Simone 2006-11302005-0530-0127
Tardiel, Charlene 2006-18162006-0521-0022
Harries-Jones, Sarah 2006-23692006-0530-0094
Thompson, Denise 2006-28922007-0530-0003
Rusteau, Harriet 2007-03282007-0530-0020
Wilson, Debby et al2007-14592007-0530-0030
Singleton, Samantha 2007-14602007-0530-0031
Gray, Stewart 2007-14612007-0530-0032
Adesua, Olusola 2007-14622007-0530-0033
Garisto, Joe 2007-14632007-0530-0034
Mitchell, Ewen 2007-14642007-0530-0035
Ward, Vaughn 2007-14652007-0530-0036
Morgan, Gracelyn 2007-14662007-0530-0037
Etienne, Cavelle 2007-14672007-0530-0038
Ramlal, Sylvia 2007-14682007-0530-0039
Azeese, Ally 2007-14692007-0530-0040
Williams, Simone et al2007-30302007-0530-0050
Rusteau, Harriet 2007-35762008-0530-0029
Rusteau, Harriet 2007-38642008-0530-0032
Manor, Quincy 2008-05482008-0530-0043
Emmanuel, Mutema 2008-05492008-0530-0044
Group B
GrievorGSB#Union File #
Adair, Allan et al2005-38572005-0530-0050
Cooney, Guy 2005-38582005-0530-0051
Perunovic, Stefanka 2005-38622005-0530-0055
Tanel, Luciano 2005-38642005-0530-0057
MacKey, Nigel 2005-38682005-0530-0061
Jagpal, Sam 2005-38722005-0530-0065
Hopkins, Byron 2005-38732005-0530-0066
Flanagan, James 2005-38772005-0530-0070
Fryginberg, Elina 2005-38782005-0530-0071
Dvorak, Jeffrey 2005-38802005-0530-0073
Durdle, Philip 2005-38812005-0530-0074
Deal, Tony 2005-38822005-0530-0075
Brown, Sidney 2005-38852005-0530-0078
Bazger, Hamza 2005-38872005-0530-0080
Parna, Elmar 2005-38922005-0530-0085
Montgomery, Mavis 2005-38972005-0530-0090
McNeely, Elizabeth 2005-38992005-0530-0092
Valaitis, Laura 2005-39002005-0530-0093
Pacheco, John 2005-39022005-0530-0095
Agnello, Tania 2005-39032005-0530-0096
Lino, Angelucci 2005-39042005-0530-0097
Ardito, Santa 2005-39052005-0530-0098
Bartosiewicz, Agnes 2005-39062005-0530-0099
Bolton, Karen2005-39072005-0530-0100
Brooks, Tim 2005-39082005-0530-0101
Fitzpatrick, Carrie2005-39112005-0530-0104
Hauery, Mark 2005-39132005-0530-0106
Haars, Catherine 2005-39142005-0530-0107
Kotsovolos, George 2005-39152005-0530-0108
Miklasz, Stanley 2005-39162005-0530-0109
Robbescheuten, Crystal 2005-39182005-0530-0111
Phillips, Stana 2005-39192005-0530-0112
Leppan-Triolo, Barbara 2005-39212005-0530-0114
Jacklyn, Denise 2005-39242005-0530-0118
Pacheco, John 2006-00402006-0530-0005
Pacheco, John 2006-00412006-0530-0006
Pacheco, John 2006-00422006-0530-0007
Christensen, Robert 2006-01382005-0530-0119
Pacheco, John 2006-06202006-0530-0016
Phillips, Stana 2006-06242006-0530-0020
Nash, Heather 2006-11312005-0530-0128
Pacheco, John 2006-22722006-0530-0086
Leppan-Triolo, Barbara 2006-31292007-0530-0013
Deal, Tony 2006-31302007-0530-0014
Miklasz, Stanley 2006-31312007-0530-0015
Nesovic, Zeljko et al2008-10292008-0530-0048
Ogle, James 2008-10302008-0530-0049