The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1993-1527.Clelland.94-10-04 ,- i.-~- ~ ~. \ r ( ~/~ G ONTARIO EMPLOYES DE LA COURONNE CROWN EMPLOYEES DE L'ONTARIO 1111 GRIEVANCE CpMMISSION DE ~ SETTLEMENT REGLEMENT BOARD DES GRIEFS 180 DUNDAS STREET WEST SUITE 2100; TORONTO, ONTARIO. MSG lZ8. TELEPHONEITELEPHONE (416) 326-1388 180, RUE DUNDAS OUEST BUREAU 2100, TORONTO (ONTARIO) MSG lZ8 FACSIMILE: ITELECOPIE (416) 326-1396 1527/93, 1534/93, 1535/93 IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION Under i THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE B~RGAINING ACT Before THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD BETWEEN OPSEU (Clelland) Grievor - and ... The Crown in Right of Ontario (Ministry of Consumer & Commercial Relations) Employer BEFORE: H Waisglass Vice-Chairperson r I A Merritt Member J. Carruthers Member FOR THE K Whitaker UNION Counsel Ryder Whitaker Wright Barristers & SOlicitors I FOR THE S Patterson EMPLOYER Counsel I Legal 'services Branch Management Board secretariat BEARING April 21, 1994 June 23, 1994 September 7, 23, 1994 I . 'f .! ( ( I - GSB 1527/93, 1534/93 & 1527/93 l IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION UNDER THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT -- BEFORE THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD BEtWEEN ( OPSEU (S Clelland) GRIEVOR -AND- THE CROWN IN RIGHT OF ONTARIO (Ministry of Consumer & Commercial Services) EMPLOYER BEFORE H J WAISGLASS Vice-Chairperson A MERRITT Employer Member J CARRUTHERS Union Member FOR THE GRIEVOR KEVIN WHITAKER, COUNSEL FOR THE EMPLOYER STEPHEN PATTERSON, COUNSEL HEARINGS April 21, June 23, Sept 7 and 23, 1994 - DECISION \ . In the course of the fourth hearing day, on September 23, 1994, the parties reached a voluntary settlement of the grievance The ,minutes of settlement have been deposited with the Grievance Settlement Board At the request of the parties, and with their agreement, the terms of_ this settlement are hereby incorporated into this Decision and are made an Order of the Board The dates of October 5th and November 29th, 1994, which had been set previously for the continuation of the hearings in this matter, are cancelled The proceedings are hereby terminated \ DATED AT HAMILTON, ONTARIO, THIS 7 ~7 -... J ~. -? I / r ,/'" - ---- / MEMBER 1/ O~- ))"L~ MEMBER ( . ----~--_.~_. ._--------~._--'-._._._-------_.__._.__._--_..~._._._-_.._..-! <:'7AJ "", \~ t; ~ ~.-.-, " l:l Q~ -../ --_.._~ ~_L~..l..___~--- _~-::- _.._._.._._-_.~--_._-_._._------"_.._._.._--- -..---.--.-------..-----.--..-.---..--..-.-.--..-,-..-.-'-'----'-"---'---"---.-'---------'-"-"-'--"-'--'-'-"--'-..-..-..-...-....-...-.."-....-.-...-..-..-..-..-..--..-..--..-...-...-...-...-"...-...-..-.....-...- ------ o~~-~_--L<:L~~2-S:::===_=. ~--=-J= --_..~_.. . . LA V\.1..,ib.____(_~C~~y,____ .- -_._-~.. 'C.[~~=_:(~.~iL :~\,__t-'- -1\-.---b.~~~~L~~--~~~==~==========:====~ ~~-=---~ ~~~ ------------------~._--------===~== <;: jJl~ ._------'---_._--------------_..._-_.._._._.!:.:::...~._._.- ._.~_..__._._._--_.._-- --.---.---. -",-,-,--,,-,-,-,-'-'-'-'-'''-''-'''-''~-'-'''-'''-''"-''''----._,,-_._._._.._.._..._-_._._._._--_._.._..~._.__._.._._- I _..._..._...__._...__.._._-----_._._._-_._.._'--~._.__...._-.'--.,..---.-.-.--.-.-....-.-.-..-...-.-.-.-.-...-.--..'--.-..-.--:-.--..--..--:-..-...-..-.-.-.-..--.----. . .. G S. ~ . ~_,_____'-~2S=_!_:i~____~Jb~___.______ ~ --.-..-... 6' (~~~.' ~~~~-=--~-=-~~=S==1=b--~~--==L~~~\~-~-~-==--=======--==-- --' -=~--;,Y..~r~=S--:-2-=-~=--==---_------ ~--_..- ._---_._._._~_._---_._._~._._._._--_._. .._-----_._-~._._------~ -~---~-- ~----~~(,t~-=---i~\0 - t __G. .) ~ .Q.j -e ~\ c:-.)t) l -. --sW --R. \A, ~..Q (" .~ ~ ~\ p\-'- JJ ~ ~~,,\ _._\ok. . '=~=~~\..QY-A~+ 1. _~ _~Wv~~~\~-\-l ~.QL. \ ...__._______N____. .-.----- _.___~k-~ C,;.. '- L9. /_.~\l ~_~p",rrt,-...e) c::~r Ji9- ~ '-.--. ---'~.Q:L '~11~ ~~. ~\.(L2 ~(- ~ 1""" ----~ . . ~)Y- ~E-1 TLG ~ ~ .- .._P--- :P-~-=- ~;:-=~~~~---=~~~-=---~--~~JL. ~-- ~:=_-== ~c.g.~~==~ldh~II ~~=_~~-------<2.~---~-_ .. .- ~..~~==--=~-=-0:,,::\l~~==--=-=-6c.~~~:L;===~-==~===~== -...-..-.-.-..-..-...-...-".-..-...-...-..-"..-..-...--.-.-..-'.-"-' .-...--.-...--..-...-.--.-...-.-....-....-...-<....-..--...---.-...-.--..-..-.-'..---.-----:-...- ..-..-...-. .._,. -.....-.-.-...-..- .'-..._--..._._~-,-_...._---.._.._,,--_.._..._.,_._._-_.._..._.. .._~,_.__._-_._._..- i>--~-==~-==--2::~~=-=----::;c~5===~-~~~-::==== _" .._..__u_._...... ._._ ._._.._..__.___.___......;.._..._, ,,__..._....~_..._.._...._. ..'t."........_.._.__..._..._....._..._._..._..._....._...._...._...._....__......__.._....__..._...._..._....._.__.._.._..._....-..._...._.....~..__..._.">_u.._...._.._.._..._..._...._..._.. ,_.. __^<'_'___'_"_"_".__'._"_"_"'_'.'_"_"_"_'''_''_'_'''_ '_'_ -. ._".____.__d:U..______~~~" ----.w..~-~~---..-~----~p-~~~b.~!1-~-l------------ ~_.---=~~-_-_~:;~~_..,~=__~=~~_-=_-~-:~-~l~_~-_:-.~_-_-_~~~~~-==~'-p-~p-~~~~=~=======~-~==,=.-~=' '7\lA.C:- \ -a-r..o.. \~_Q;':>'..D~.__~ \L--\.'-.. " ~-~--_._.~-~_.__._-_.__._._.- :::_~____Jd..\.~l..~~__~_ (<->~~~~-=-~~+====- -- ~E:=-~~~L~=ru--_{ul-~~--= I .~----~~--~..~~-~ =--~=:J{-~---------- 1- , . ~--'-------------'-'------C'" . . . ----~g~-~~~l..-'-c'J~----~--R"'-~~~---cl:::l~----- ~=~~~==,~~ ~~]------~.0 ---~~====~~_~~=~~j~~:g:~==~~~k~===========-- -=-=-=-=lll---= ,,~-Jl-';-F~~~~~~~~[~=~~==~========----- ~=~i~==~~~~~~~~==f~~=~=- - -' .-. i ~-- ----------------- ~~&~~---~~--==~~p t-~--~~---------- :f ---~ ~~~'\;;7Q..( '-'~'-. . ._-_._----_._----------~---_._---~--- . .. ---- ----~-~--;:s("-~~~: ~ _~l ~ ~-=h.Q ,-.-------" . -.--..---'-)-'.~-----..-.---..----.-.-.--------.--.---:----V. . _____--$ Iv--V\.^- ~ ..s-~.:':.::__._t\ L-v,--SJ {..L ..--. . C#-~u .~d'v J-~~ ),~_~c:;J) t.-.-J \ <\L .}\- -------~ ~ '=~~__~cQ~ '-~~ ~ -.. b.L~~~~~-v~ ~. .0\ =--==C"-- ~ \-.~h ~_.\t...-~c \,L.. .. Gi.. ,- ~^~\":l~~ · ,- c:; l "'" \. \A.. -.---~-- ~~-J . - ,j ., I ---..--.----- , ~. I- _._,--~..~-'-~._-- ~.----::-- .' <:::- . I Q ( JU-' ==ro= ~. A J"""""V ~..----,~----~..t::---~.~-?~--L-----.G.3..!----:.5-------.- _______L___~___L---. =-~====~ --~=;~~\-~- -p-.t bJV\..L~.\\ t=~ ~-~ ~~~~-=-~=-=:~~I~~---====.=~-~~-~-~~'~=====~]--===~=~fj=~~~f~-~-~~~-~--~== --~==~~~~~~i=;=~~~~~I~~~~~~~~ .--..-.--,----.-.-.---- ------..--..---...-..- .--.. -.---.-....-.-..-_..~.-_.-...-..-._...-..-.- .-.--.--:.I..-.-...-..-....-..-.-.-.-..-..-.-...-.--..-.-.-..-..-..--...---...--.---..-..-..- .--.----.--. ._..__...__._,__ ____._._._._ .._._..__,_.._._.._.' _ _ ~ . .V'- ('-I....... . . ck.. . ~ '.. ~I ~---~----------------~--,---~--------~---------- ,_._....,.'_~._______._________..___._.,_..____.__.._ .____.__.._._..._._....__._._...._..._ .__n_..__..._.._n_n_n'_"_'_'_'_..__._nn_n__._'"_..__._...._._.__,_.____.___~____.._._.._..___...___,_._____.__._._._._ \,--)-,-.,,,.~~.f~:J~-----------J\-,--,--..-lS.~....l----~{~_L_____~----.--\..S-~~--;-,-.---.---- ~/ ,\. ~ '- v--f~~3-=::t "~~.J~2 -\-~-_._---_._._._._- ....- --- ' . f-l J\> ~ Q; ~__~~~_~I~~l_==~~~~-=~~__~~~~'~~~~_-=-~__._ - '~ " -S{----~----------~~--- <:.) r ~ ~~~~=- _____._s.j~.________\.~_ .__ .____E~,-____~:....___.:.,,_.___________ -_dJ cO" ~r\- ~--------_._---- \.- ~ ~lli2~-----U-L;jJ-~-~-==>--,---------- ---- Af-.~~~~;:'===~- d=~==;=====~~:~:==,=============_= c...,,:> ---- -- ___.__.____.____._..___._._____H._._.__._.___..._._.__.__.__.__.___ ----- --'--_._---:---..__._--_._-_.._~--'------_._--_.._._.._..._..__._._.._. ---~-~~ .---------------------~-------.----:.tL;--.------- (c ~L~~L----,-~-~1:B~2---.~.----..--..--.--~L~~--.._--.---_,____ -,-------~------~-.-----~--------b~~~~====-fu-~~====hI\-~~~==:=====- ~ .-..-.-.-.----.------.-.-._.._._0__._._---.---..---.-._ .. - - . ..._-----------------~.,-------------------- ~~ ~ ~~--':[_~Q f2~.=_~_._____bL~~.R.___)2,.~L__~_ .. -_..--- .' .... '-'--~!'.. . -_._----~-- h-45l1~--~_P------~~,--~~-----_----,-~ i~ --~--i---~'5 ~ .-. "-l_~~_~_~~-"----~ili~~-----~ I ---------~) ---- - -5LJc-:?___~\ \/7- cP- ,.. '- I J '--" ~.v~,~~ '-..>- ~.Q G-........:~ c9c-~ S ) ___.H___ -___._._.~=~~.=~'-~==~===~-~~~~~-~~~:~~-----~=--=l~-~ls:&=-~~-=-_=:f\----------~---- ------.-.--------- r:;; ----------------------- ~'I-~----~~-~"bC------~-:-"----'~~~-3--.,m----', -- ,.. -'----------,---------- -...-.--~:========-=====---7-=~~~~--~--~=:~~=~:-~~~===~==~~;-~~;~-=~-=--~-~=-=-~==-----=---=~~~--- . . .~.,_u.._.._.._.______.___.___._._..__._.._,__.._.,__.._'_.._..'_n'_"'_""_"_h_n_u__'_"_"_n._n__n_._"_,,_u_u._ ._..._._.._..._._._._.._.._..._..._...._.._._._h_._..._._.._._..____._.,._.._.__._._..._.._._.._..._.._._.........._......:H.___._ __n_"_""'_"_"'_'_'__'__'__'__"_"_._._.._.__n__..._n_.._._."._.........._.._.__..._,..._._..._...._..._..._...__...._...._,.._,._,_._...._...._...,.:.-...__"_.._~.,'_.,._..._.__,.__._.._.'__'_"_"_"_"_n'_'._n_"_'_"_"_"_'_"_'_"__,,_._,,_'_'_'__'_~u______"~ , @=====-----=3-=~-~===-~:~=====-::=~::lili~~~-~~=1l4:-:'-~-~--~R-~_~_~~~~_-====~=,==__~=~ ,~~~-~=-=--~-6~=~=====~~-:~~;===~~=~g;~~~C~~===~=== n__., .__._._'__'_....,N_'~_.____._..._.._'.__.._._._h_.,__.._...~_"_'_',_,,_ f'\_f r ^\ f-'h 0 J~---' ,<\l~--_~-~-~0~~'-~7--~-~\~--~~==]l:i- I-=='==~=~~=-==- .' . L [;) .' ~____._______._'_._o_____o__.__.____.____._o_._._.~.._.o_..~._._o"_''-_'__'_''_'o_._o_._.._____ ~ (~" ..e .a_~__o_~___~~JQ~-&I__)____.________ _.___"_..______ , ___"______.___,_._,_._,.~._._..._.._..._.....____....__.._"___'__',__.__.._n,_'_._._.._n_.._"._...__.._.u_n_.._._.._u._,...._,..._._..._._._..._._...__._._..._..,__~_..._...,_._ ._..~._"_,._'._,._. L J2 v.~.,~~ ~-e .~~~--__,.,q_~______C~_Ll~~~~~!__,-______ _--~--~_--h---~~~--=~~~-==~--==- .-. LQ 22..>> jL .~-----J\----~--~-~~~----~=~~~;~~~~=~~====~--==== -----,----~ ! .; ~~~~~:;~~~=~~~)~~;~~~-~=-~==~-~====~=~=~=--========- _____._.______.__________.___.__.__,._._._._..._.._._._~._._._...__._.._..__..~_.._.._._...___.,.L.___._.,_,'_'_"'_'_'_'_"'_"_"_"_"_"_'__"_'_'_"_'_"__'_.._.._.._...____.__._.____..__ -------------e-~pl~J0-C;-~-,-.--.----.---.-,.-- ..;..--.--------------.----------------------.-- -- . . .*-..-..-.-..-...-.-...........-..--.-..--.-..--.--..-.-.-..-.-.-..--.--.-..-.-..---.-... . .~,-,-,,_.,-,- __'._ -.--...---.------...-..-.-.-._._0_..._-..-----.--.-..-.-__'_"_._.._n..._..',__"__"_'_"__'''_'_._''___''_''_''__"_._'__'_"_'_'_"_~'_"__"_'._'_'___'_.__"'_'_'__'_.__.--_.__._~ '-- ~~_.__o_~__oo__~~11_~,-___~=~[~-~~~_TI_~~_____~M_~--------'- ________ t:i~Lu-~-~~~~~_=__===:~:i=~===~=~=~~~===~l=~.~.LQ-.:=(-------0- J2---------.-.----- . o_____~__-- u c,__()-L~~---o~~--.-"---~~---~~ :r~---~~-~ L.-c:- ~ _....:2___,=] ____Jl.w..___~~_ ( $..12.. 5 -V ~ +- - CJ r C(.~2~~ '2:~_-=~~J1- ~~;~.~..A-..--A. _____ ~~"-~---~L~S,l-'-~-L~~~=--~~~- I ~~(~------_. I~~_____o__________________ _..__.__._-:--~ . ......--:- '-.__-'-_0__- . ____.__ I _..___.'\:>~_'~~_~____~~___,__._~..~_~~_____.~~------_~=>-,L~_-R!::-'J-~.--~--------.- I -------..-.-.---0-------..--.----.-.-,--..-.-.-.-..,-....,,-.._.___._..__.._.o_._.._.._o_._._____.___,__,____~__--.-.--..-.--.-.,--.- .. __.o____,S_~~-----_'o-_~~'}=}-~\---'------- . ) I .--.-.---0.----..------.-.-.--.-----.-..-.-.-.-.--.-..-.-0-.-.--..-...-..-.----.-..-...-.-..-.-.-..-.-.-.-..--.-----.-.-------.----- ~=~~~;;p;*~~-=-=~:~~~:=~~=~. ~-~~--==-~~~~----~==~~ ___._.________i \ ~_____._._c_..___________._____-~..~====~==~~_-~==.IT=::;:====='=============_-==_~=- _..._.._..._.._.__.._..____._.._._.__.._..____...__._.._...__.._.._..._..._..__..__._..__,.._..._..._..._n.._....._... ._...._.......;...._._ .._'.._" _._...._m_..._m.:-...._...._..._..._...._.._...._.._.m_.._..._...___._..._.._..._...._ m_..._..._..._.._.._..._..___.....:..._.._...._. .._._m_'_..___"__ -_.._~._._._-_._._.__._.-:---_._.__._---_..._.._.~._...._.-...--..-..-.-....-...-.-.-..--..---.-..-..-..-..-..-..--..-.._..._~.._...._.._._..__..~._.._.._...._.._..._.._..._...._.._..-_._.._..._.._-_..__.._..._._._..~_._-- _._~._._.._..__._._..- _ --'---'--- ------.-...-..........-..-..-.-...-...----.--....-..-.--...-----...-..-.--..-....-,.-...--.-....--.-..-.. .-.. ._..~_..._...._. ._...~..."_...._..._.._....._....- -..-...-..--.-....- .-..-...---..-.-.-..--.-.....-...-... -..-..-.-..-..-..-...........-...-....-..-.-..---..-..--., "-:!--- 0-'-- -.:::;.::=::::;;:.___..___~,-.-.-..- ._.._..=._ .._.._...__....~_....,..._..._ ...'...-..7. ._.._...... .-..-..-..-..0_...-...-..-....-.-....-....-..-,..- ._. _"_'''_''_''__''';-''_'_' .__.._..._...__._.._..._.._..~ -------------.-..-.--.--.-.---..--..-..-.-.-..-.-.-.-.'-"-"- ~./ __________,__________========~&~:x_====~~-====~~_~~______~_-= ------- ~=_=_~_2\&2 \1 \ ~ ~ =-=s;--~~~~-=--'=~-:L~~-:x========-=-~=~=~-=-=-~====: ._._-_._-~-_.__._-_._._._-------_._-_.__._._-_._- ~~~=-b be-r - ~s-'!-_~i~ \~.~~______.____._=_~=_~~__~_=_-=______~__========~__=====- -_._~.._-------_.__._-_.~.__._-_._...__._.__._.._._._-,-""-"'-'.-'-"-"-'--"-"-..--..-...-..-.'-"---'-..-.---.----.-. -.-- ~-S~~-~t~~--==-J-=~~~:0b-~=~--~--~~--=======.==--= ._--_._._-------'-~---_._--_.__.__..__._._._._--_._------..--.---.--.------.---.----..--.-.---.-- ._______1r1 ~ _._~~~i~' "-l--J---{2-~J_~~~.~:)_____.:!1~,.__._.__.._b:1L-"-------.--.,____.._____ - - -- - ----C '- \r --::n=-- - ---:~A~~ - .- - - - := ::---.--f---~--~~~I-----.---~----------------- ~. -.----~~Ll)(:LC------'3-.---- ..---- ~u_,~---,-" . '. 3lA.) c.IXf----..,---~.D r----J2::f-::---.~--.~----~-~ .------- . ~ -~-------------_._-~ . . . . ~.. . ..-- '.-.----.--.---.-.-----------.-.-----.--.-..--:---..]- . ---~ --\ ~ :(1...!c1_~~ .-I-~~-~-\~-c----'-~ ,-,.....--.. ----_.__._------_.__._._'-_._---'----------_._._---_._~ -- ,-------.k:~-~-----~,-----~~~-,,-~~\.y_J-.----9-~41.Q~-\,3:..Q -\.. . --. ~'-,,~ ._...~_.._._--_._._------- 0.:.9. v.s:t. r~ <:...~.d~)..Ql~ \'I...o;...-O'J C.JO )J{ ~~~-L.e~~ \~ d\ ~ , ._---~~ n~,\ . I \ -'-- -- '- . 'le . --. . ~ ,--~---o.- ~~. , -- ~ ________~~_llJf j}/i0__~~_~.~~--t\ \.'--\..... ~ ----.----.-.-. '- -.----- '----_.__._~_._---_._._---_._._-_.._._-_._._.._..._._.-'-'-"-'-"---'-'-'--'---'--.--.-'-'-'-'-.-..-.'-'-"._.~-_._------- ---- , - _...__........_........_._----_..__._-_.._'--.--..~~_._.__.._.-..--..-.-..-..-..--.-.-----.------'--.--------,..---- ,______.f:--~,_"_____~\.~" L_"')______ . ===-----~e~_=K=~=3J:~~--=-=--===--======-== -._-- ------ ~(-L-C"'-~l~ ., . "-- .-..----... . - - .-.- _.. -.-.-.-..--.-.-..-.-.-.--.-----.-.-..-...-..-..--.-.-.'-._._-_.~._--_..:--.~.__._._.._._-_._-- .-.--...-..-.-.--..-------..--..--,--..-.--..-.-.-.-..-.---..._.._.._..._.._._._._.~.._...._.__.._.._...._._..._.._u___._.._._..___,__._____.._._..._u._..._..._.._._.._..___._.~.._..._...__"__,_",_,_,_,_,,,__,,_,,"_.._.._.._~.___._.._._ _.._-.._--_.._._-_._..--:--_._---~._._._.._- "_"'_"'_"_'''__'_-_'_'__''-:''-''---'-''-'''--'"-''--''-'~'''-''- .--..-.--..---...-..-.-..-.--...-..--...:......-..-....-.-.-.-......::..-.-..--.-.-.-.-.--.--.-.-.--.-......-.-.-- ____.~_.________.,__-.-___'u_._.___.._._..__..__._._._____...._._._._.__.__.._.._.._....._'"_ _...._...._..._ _..._.._..._..._',__.__.._.._~.........._...._u_._.__._.._.._...__.._.._._._._.____._.._u_._._.__._.___ - - - - --------~--- - - .~ - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - .--- - - - _.._~_.._~.._..._...._..,__.,,_..___.._u._.._.._..._.".______._..._..u____"__'_"_."_"'_'_'_'_"_"_'"_"_'__"_"_,, ._.._.._.._.___...._._ ..-..--.-.-.-.----,.-.-.-----'-..-.--..-..-..-------.--..-..-.-.--.-.-..-.-.-...-...-..-..----.-..----.-...-..--.--\--.-----..---.-.-.--.-.-,---.--.--.-..--.--- I ' ---.---.----.-.----.-..--.-.--..--.-.----..--....__..____._.__._..__..._........;..._...._..__.._.._.._._H_.._u_.._..._..__.._...._._..._._.._.__._..________.._..._..._._._.__._._._.._.____.___._ '0' -.-..- .-.,-.-.-...--.---.-...-..--..---.-----.-....--.----..-.-..--~--_.._.._._..._--_..._.._._.._."_.._..._....._..._.._._. -..-...-...-.----...--..-.....-....-....-..-..-.-...-...-....-...-..-...-..-...-..-, .-....-.-..-...-..-..-..-.--..--.-.-.-..-.-.-...-..-..-.--..-.