HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-0652.Union.19-10-17 Decision
Crown Employees Grievance Settlement
Board
Suite 600
180 Dundas St. West
Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388
Fax (416) 326-1396
Commission de
règlement des griefs
des employés de la
Couronne
Bureau 600
180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tél. : (416) 326-1388
Téléc. : (416) 326-1396
GSB#2015-0652; 2010-2499
UNION#2015-0108-0004; 2010-0108-0048
Additional files are attached in Appendix “A”
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Union) Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of the Solicitor General) Employer
BEFORE Ken Petryshen Arbitrator
FOR THE UNION John Brewin
Ryder Wright Blair & Holmes LLP
Counsel
FOR THE EMPLOYER George Parris
Treasury Board Secretariat
Legal Services Branch
Counsel
TELECONFERENCE October 16, 2019
- 2 -
Decision
[1] The two matters before me are contained within file numbers 2010-2499 et
al. and 2015-0652. The grievances in these matters allege that the Employer failed to
comply with its scheduling obligations under different compressed work agreements at
the Elgin Middlesex Detention Centre (“EMDC”). I released a decision for file number
2010-2499 et al. on September 12, 2019 in which I indicated that the parties should be
in a position to now resolve the relevant grievances.
[2] At a hearing on September 27, 2019 for File Number 2015-0652, I discussed
with counsel ways to move forward with these cases to facilitate a resolution of the
grievances. This subject was further discussed during a conference call held on
October 16, 2019. After hearing from counsel during the conference call, I advised
them that I would make directions to both parties in order to ensure that they would be
in a position to focus on the remaining remedial issues in dispute for the mediation
scheduled for November 14, 2019. Accordingly, for purposes of the upcoming
mediation only and without prejudice to the positions a party might take in any future
litigation of the grievances, I hereby direct each party to prepare and provide to counsel
opposite a written outline of its position on the monetary value of any outstanding
remedy for both matters, along with the rationale for its position, by no later than
November 8, 2019.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 17th day of October, 2019.
“Ken Petryshen”
Ken Petryshen, Arbitrator
- 3 -
APPENDIX “A”
GSB# Grievor Union File #
2010-2500 Klir, David 2010-0108-0049
2010-2501 Wust, Harry 2010-0108-0050
2010-2502 Fraleigh, Robert 2010-0108-0051
2010-2503 Winegarden,
Kenneth
2010-0108-0052
2010-2504 McDonald, Scott 2010-0108-0053
2010-2825 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0005
2010-2826 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0006
2010-2827 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0007
2010-2828 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0008
2010-2829 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0009
2010-2830 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0010
2010-2831 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0011
2010-2832 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0012
2010-2833 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0013
2010-2834 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0014
2010-2835 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0015
2010-2836 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0016
2010-2837 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0017
2010-2880 MacLean, Graeme 2011-0108-0018
2010-2881 MacLean, Graeme 2011-0108-0019
2010-2882 Prentice, Andrew 2011-0108-0020
2010-2883 Prentice, Andrew 2011-0108-0021
2010-2884 Prentice, Andrew 2011-0108-0022
2010-2885 Prentice, Andrew 2011-0108-0023
2010-2886 Prentice, Andrew 2011-0108-0024
2010-2887 Townsend,
Rebecca
2011-0108-0025
2010-2888 Townsend,
Rebecca
2011-0108-0026
2010-2889 Townsend,
Rebecca
2011-0108-0027
2010-2890 Townsend,
Rebecca
2011-0108-0028
2010-2891 Cecchin, Jim 2011-0108-0029
2010-2892 Cecchin, Jim 2011-0108-0030
2010-2893 Cecchin, Jim 2011-0108-0031
2010-2894 Cecchin, Jim 2011-0108-0032
2010-2923 MacLean, Graeme 2011-0108-0034
2011-0251 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0037
2011-0252 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0038
2011-0253 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0039
2011-0254 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0040
- 4 -
2011-0255 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0041
2011-0256 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0042
2011-0257 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0043
2011-0258 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0044
2011-0259 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0045
2011-0260 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0046
2011-0261 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0047
2011-0262 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0048
2011-0263 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0049
2011-0264 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0050
2011-0265 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0051
2011-0266 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0052
2011-0267 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0053
2011-0268 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0054
2011-0269 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0055
2011-0270 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0057
2011-0271 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0058
2011-0272 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0059
2011-0273 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0060
2011-0274 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0061
2011-0275 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0062
2011-0562 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0067
2011-0563 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0068
2011-0564 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0069
2011-0565 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0070
2011-0566 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0071
2011-0567 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0072
2011-0582 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0073
2011-0598 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0056
2011-0615 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0076
2011-0636 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0077
2011-0637 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0078
2011-0638 Farlow, Deborah 2011-0108-0079
2011-0660 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0080
2011-0661 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0081
2011-0662 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0082
2011-0663 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0083
2011-0664 Fraleigh, Robert 2011-0108-0084
2011-0665 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0085
2011-0666 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0086
2011-0667 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0087
2011-0668 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0088
2011-0669 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0089
2011-0670 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0090
2011-0671 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0091
2011-0672 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0092
- 5 -
2011-0673 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0093
2011-0752 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0094
2011-0753 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0095
2011-0754 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0096
2011-0755 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0098
2011-1039 MacLean, Graeme 2011-0108-0101
2011-1040 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0102
2011-1041 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0103
2011-1043 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0105
2011-1044 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0106
2011-1045 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0107
2011-1046 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0108
2011-1047 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0109
2011-1048 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0110
2011-1062 Baker, Joshua 2011-0108-0097
2011-2068 Kennett, Rick 2011-0108-0112
2011-2071 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0115
2011-2072 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0116
2011-2073 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0117
2011-2074 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0118
2011-2075 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0119
2011-2076 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0120
2011-2077 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0121
2011-2078 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0122
2011-2079 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0123
2011-2080 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0124
2011-2081 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0125
2011-2082 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0126
2011-2083 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0127
2011-2084 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0128
2011-2085 Deyell, Robert 2011-0108-0129
2011-2134 MacLean, Graeme 2011-0108-0131
2011-2666 Coull, James et al 2011-0108-0135
2011-2846 Union 2011-0108-0134