HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-3478.Garcia.22-03-04 Decision
Crown Employees Grievance Settlement
Board
Suite 600
180 Dundas St. West
Toronto, Ontario M5G 1Z8
Tel. (416) 326-1388
Commission de
règlement des griefs
des employés de la
Couronne
Bureau 600
180, rue Dundas Ouest
Toronto (Ontario) M5G 1Z8
Tél. : (416) 326-1388
GSB#2018-3478
UNION# 2018-0108-0047
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Garcia) Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of the Solicitor General) Employer
BEFORE Brian P. Sheehan Arbitrator
FOR THE UNION Gregg Gray
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
Grievance Officer
FOR THE EMPLOYER Justin O’Gorman
Treasury Board Secretariat
Employee Relations Advisor
HEARING January 18, 2022 (via Videoconference
- 2 -
Decision
[1] In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb
process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was agreed that overtime
grievances would be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the
stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely
manner to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each
institution. Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped
that these monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances.
[2] It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to
deal exclusively with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would
meet to attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining
disputes would be put before this Board.
[3] In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the
parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. Since that time a
number of sessions have been held and various decisions rendered. The process
has not been altered and continues to serve the parties well.
[4] The grievances determined herein were dealt with on January 18, 2022.
[5] Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and made submissions
regarding the various disputes. Attached as Appendix A is the list of grievances
and the disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors
as set out in the attached appendix are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate
less statutory deductions.
[6] I remain seized.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 4th day of March 2022.
“Brian P. Sheehan”
_______________________
Brian P. Sheehan, Arbitrator
- 3 -
APPENDIX A
CASE NAME FIRST NAME OPSEU # GSB # CASE DATE Results
GARCIA Daniel 2018-0108-0047 2018-3478 22-Nov-18 Upheld - 16 hours OT
BURNUP Janet 2020-0135-0001 2019-2702 19-Jan-20 Dismissed
CRAGG Adam 2020-0135-0024 2020-1290 10-Jul-20 Dismissed
STOCKFISH Glenn 2013-0234-0067 2013-0977 26-May-13 Upheld - 12 hours OT
STOCKFISH Glenn 2013-0234-0068 2013-0978 26-May-13 Upheld - 12 hours OT
COFFIN Robert 2018-0252-0010 2018-1801 28-Jun-18 Upheld - 8 hours OT
GHALY Chris 2019-0252-0027 2019-2190 09-Oct-19
Upheld in part - 4 hours
ST; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
MACKENZIE Ryan 2018-0252-0027 2019-0259 15-Dec-18 Upheld - 12 hours Double
Time
RIDSDALE Christopher 2019-0252-0015 2019-0771 15-May-19 Upheld - 4 hours OT
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0041 2019-2873 09-May-19 Upheld - 8 hours OT
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0042 2019-2874 09-May-19 Upheld - 8 hours OT
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0043 2019-2875 09-May-19 Upheld - 6 hours OT
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0044 2019-2876 10-May-19 Dismissed
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0045 2019-2877 10-Jun-19 Dismissed
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0046 2019-2878 18-Jun-19 Upheld - 6 hours OT
SPITZIG Kurtis 2019-0252-0047 2019-2879 18-Jun-19 Upheld - 8 hours OT
VALOVICH Michael 2016-0252-0014 2016-2551 24-Nov-16 Dismissed
VALOVICH Michael 2017-0252-0016 2018-1904 11-Nov-17 Upheld - 10 hours OT
WILSON Shannon 2018-0252-0003 2018-0912 12-Feb-18
Upheld - 1 hour ST and 11
hours OT; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
AARNAMO Jennifer 2015-0708-0001 2014-4579 11-Jan-15
Upheld - 4 hours ST and 8
hours OT; and applicable
adjustment to CSD
AARNAMO Jennifer 2012-0708-0013 2012-4714 12-Dec-12 Upheld - 4 hours ST
SAINDON Andy 2020-0737-0008 2020-0672 29-Apr-20 Upheld - 8 hours OT
HUTCHINSON Bryan 2017-0708-0010 2017-1027 07-May-17 Upheld - 12 hours OT
AASHDIR Nitin 2019-0234-0301 2019-2635 19-Dec-19 Dismissed
BETLEJ Joanna 2019-0234-0265 2019-2107 05-Nov-19 Upheld - 10 hours OT
BRUSSE Pamela 2018-0234-0169 2018-1463 28-Jun-18 Dismissed
AASHDIR Nitin 2019-0234-0302 2019-2673 19-Dec-19 Upheld - 8 hours OT
BISSCHOP Natashia 2019-0234-0071 2018-3783 12-Feb-19 Dismissed
BISSCHOP Natashia 2018-0234-0146 2018-1367 20-Jun-18 Dismissed
FAULKNER Laurie-Ann 2018-0234-0010 2017-3624 04-Jan-18 Dismissed
- 4 -
CASE NAME FIRST NAME OPSEU # GSB # CASE DATE Results
FAULKNER Catherine 2018-0234-0123 2018-0908 13-Apr-18 Dismissed
GRAHAM Ryan 2019-0234-0122 2019-0298 25-Mar-19 Dismissed
JACKSON Jack 2019-0234-0094 2018-3973 11-Feb-19 Dismissed
D'ANDREA Kevin 2016-0234-0202 2016-2165 08-Dec-16 Dismissed
MOUSKOS Antonios 2020-0234-0081 2020-0532 24-Apr-20 Dismissed
WILES Joseph 2020-0234-0074 2020-0525 07-May-20 Upheld - 8 hours OT
D'ANDREA Kevin 2019-0234-0081 2018-3863 31-Jan-19 Upheld - 12 hours OT
CASULLO Emidio 2016-0234-0201 2016-2164 13-Dec-16 Upheld - 4 hours OT
DAKROUB Mohamad 2018-0234-0026 2017-3765 17-Jan-18 Upheld - 8 hours OT
RICHARDS James 2018-0234-0029 2017-3768 22-Jan-18 Upheld - 8 hours OT
WALTON Andrew 2019-0234-0207 2019-1500 31-Jul-19 Upheld - 5 hours OT, 5
hours ST
DINSMORE Mark 2016-0247-0025 2016-1801 09-Aug-16 Dismissed
HERRIOTT Bradley 2017-0247-0014 2016-2742 10-Feb-17 Upheld - 12 hours OT
KLEMENT Michael 2016-0247-0010 2016-0901 01-Jul-16 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0086 2020-0537 19-Apr-20 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2019-0234-0088 2018-3943 20-Feb-19 Upheld - 5 hours OT
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0115 2020-1210 03-Jul-20 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2018-0234-0137 2018-1187 21-May-18 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2018-0234-0291 2018-3052 09-Nov-18 Upheld - 10 hours OT
HOLWELL Pauline 2018-0234-0258 2018-2835 10-Oct-18 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2018-0234-0287 2018-3048 31-Oct-18 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2018-0234-0281 2018-2889 17-Oct-18 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2019-0234-0091 2018-3970 26-Feb-19 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2019-0234-0090 2018-3969 26-Feb-19 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2019-0234-0074 2018-3856 12-Feb-19 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2019-0234-0075 2018-3857 13-Feb-19 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2018-0234-0194 2018-1684 23-Jul-18 Dismissed
GROVES Maurice 2018-0234-0265 2018-2842 12-Oct-18 Upheld - 8 hours OT
GROVES Maurice 2018-0234-0266 2018-2843 12-Oct-18 Upheld - 10 hours OT
DO REGO Melissa 2018-0234-0225 2018-2007 11-Jul-18 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0110 2020-1136 18-Jun-20 Upheld - 12 hours OT
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0162 2020-1855 16-Sep-20 Upheld - 12 hours OT
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0159 2020-1852 16-Sep-20 Dismissed
HOLWELL Pauline 2020-0234-0158 2020-1851 05-Sep-20 Upheld - 8 hours OT
DANCE Kurtis 2019-0234-0142 2019-0505 28-Feb-19 Upheld - 8 hours ST
CASIELLO Victoria 2021-0234-0005 2020-2527 04-Jan-21 Upheld - 12 hours OT
DISTASI Alexander 2021-0234-0011 2020-2638 25-Jan-21 Upheld - 12 hours OT