Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010-0562.Varcoe.11-04-05 Decision Commission de Crown Employees Grievance UqJOHPHQWGHV Settlement Board griefs GHVHPSOR\pVGHOD Couronne Suite 600 180 Dundas St. West Bureau 600 Toronto, Ontario M5G 180, rue Dundas Ouest 1Z8 Toronto (Ontario) M5G Tel. (416) 326-1388 1Z8 Fax (416) 326-1396 7pO   7pOpF   GSB#2010-0562 UNION#2010-0212-0010 IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION Under THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT Before THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD BETWEEN Ontario Public Service Employees Union (Varcoe) Union - and - The Crown in Right of Ontario (Ministry of Attorney General) Employer BEFOREVice-Chair Felicity D. Briggs FOR THE UNION Stephen Giles Ontario Public Service Employees Union Grievance Officer FOR THE EMPLOYER Peter Dailleboust Ministry of Government Services Legal Services Branch Counsel HEARINGMarch 28, 2011. - 2 - Decision á ßóÎÈÔ×ÙÍÐÐ×ÙÈÓÆ×ÚÛÊÕÛÓÎÓÎÕÎ×ÕÍÈÓÛÈÓÍÎÉÈÔÛÈÈÍÍÑÌÐÛÙ×ÓÎ  ÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÕÊ××ØÈÍÓÎÉ×ÊÈÛÎ×ÅûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÓÎÈÍÈÔ×ùÍÐÐ×ÙÈÓÆ× ûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈèÔÛÈÌÊÍÆÓÉÓÍÎÌÊÍÆÓØ×ØÖÍÊÛÙÔÛÎÕ×ÍÖÉÈÛÈÇÉÖÍÊÛ ÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖ×ÏÌÐÍÃ××ÉÖÊÍÏÖÓÄ×ØÈ×ÊÏÈÍÈÔ×Î×ÅÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃÍÖ ©ÖÐ×ÄÓÚÐ×ÌÛÊÈÈÓÏרÔ×Ê×ÓÎÛÖÈ×ÊÊ×Ö×ÊÊ×ØÈÍÛÉ©öìè¨ûÈÈÔ×ÍÇÈÉ×È ÈÔ×÷ÏÌÐÍÃ×ÊÊ×Ö×ÊÊ×ØÈÍÈÔÓÉÓÎÓÈÓÛÈÓÆ×ÛÉÈÔשê×ÆÓÈÛÐÓÂ×ØåÍÊÑÖÍÊÙ× ìÊÍÒ×ÙȨ©êåì¨ûÉÍÖòÛÎÇÛÊà  ÓÈÔÛÉÚ××ÎÙÍÏÏÍÎÐà ÑÎÍÅÎÛÉ©óÎÈ×ÕÊÛÈ×ØðÛÚÍÇÊê×ÐÛÈÓÍÎÉéÈÊÛÈ×ÕèÍÊ©óðêé¨ á èÔÓÉÙÔÛÎÕ×ÚÊÍÇÕÔÈÛÚÍÇÈÏÛÎÃ×ÏÌÐÍÃ××ËÇ×ÉÈÓÍÎÉÛÎØ ÇÐÈÓÏÛÈ×ÐÃÛÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖØÓÉÌÇÈ×É ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×É á ßúÃÛÐÐÛÙÙÍÇÎÈÉÈÔ×Ê×Å×Ê×ÛÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÛÊ×ÛÉÓÎÈÔ×ÓÎÓÈÓÛÐÐÛÎÕÇÛÕ× ÍÖûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÙÛÈÓÍÎûÙÙÍÊØÓÎÕÐÃÓÎÛÎ×ÖÖÍÊÈ ÈÍÙÍÎÈÓÎÇ×ÈÍÅÍÊÑÈÍÕ×ÈÔ×ÊÈÔÊÍÇÕÔÏÛÎÃÍÖÈÔ×ÓØ×ÎÈÓÖÓ×Ø ÌÊÍÚÐ×ÏÛÊ×ÛÉÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÎ×ÕÍÈÓÛÈ×ØÛÉ×ÊÓ×ÉÍÖÛÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈÉ Ê×ÕÛÊØÓÎÕÈÔ×ÆÛÊÓÍÇÉÏÛÈÈ×ÊÉÎ××ØÓÎÕÈÍÚ×ÛØØÊ×ÉÉ×Ø ûØØÓÈÓÍÎÛÐÐÃÓÎÛÎÍÎÕÍÓÎÕ×ÖÖÍÊÈÈÍÊ×ÉÍÐÆ×ÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÓÉÉÇ×ÉÈÔÛÈ ÙÍÎÈÓÎÇ×ØÈÍÛÊÓÉ×ÛÏ×ÎØÏ×ÎÈÉÅ×Ê×ÏÛØ×ÈÍûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÓÎÈÔ× Î×ÄÈÛÎØÎÍÅÙÇÊÊ×ÎÈùÍÐÐ×ÙÈÓÆ×ûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈ áßíÎé×ÌÈ×ÏÚ×Ê  ÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÕÊ××ØÈÍÛÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖ ÛÏ×ÎØÏ×ÎÈÉÓÎÛÖÛÓÊÐÃÙÍÏÌÊ×Ô×ÎÉÓÆ×ï×ÏÍÊÛÎØÇÏÍÖ ûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈèÔÓÉûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈÊ×ÉÍÐÆ×ØÈÔ×ÓØ×ÎÈÓÖÓ×ØØÓÉÌÇÈ×ÉÈÔÛÈ ÔÛØÚ××ÎÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÛÎØÖÇÊÈÔ×ÊÊ×ÙÍÕÎÓÂ×ØÈÔÛÈÖÇÈÇÊ× ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÏÓÕÔÈÛÊÓÉ×óÎÐÛÊÕ×Ï×ÛÉÇÊ×ÈÔ×ÛÏ×ÎØÏ×ÎÈÉÛÕÊ××Ø ÇÌÍÎÓÎÈÔ×é×ÌÈ×ÏÚ×Ê  ï×ÏÍÊÛÎØÇÏÍÖûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈÅ×Ê× ÓÎÙÍÊÌÍÊÛÈ×ØÓÎÈÍûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÈÔ×ÙÇÊÊ×ÎÈùÍÐÐ×ÙÈÓÆ×ûÕÊ××Ï×ÎÈ - 3 - áßéÓÎÙ×é×ÌÈ×ÏÚ×ÊÍÖ ÓÏÛÈ×ÐÃÈÅÍÔÇÎØÊ×ØÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×É ÔÛÆ×Ú××ÎÖÓÐ×ØóÎÛÎ×ÖÖÍÊÈÈÍÊ×ÉÍÐÆ×ÈÔ×É×ÏÛÈÈ×ÊÉ×ÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÈÐÃÈÔ× ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÅÍÊÑ×ØÈÍÕ×ÈÔ×ÊÈÍÙÊ×ÛÈ×ÛÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÖÍÊÈÔ××ÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÈ ÐÓÈÓÕÛÈÓÍÎÍÖÛÐÐÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÓÉÉÇ×ÉèÍÈÔÛÈ×ÎØÛÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖ ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÔÛÆ×Ú××ÎÔ×ÛÊØÛÎØØ×ÙÓØ×ØÚÃÈÔ×úÍÛÊØèÔÍÉ× Ø×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÉÔÛÆ×Ê×ÉÍÐÆ×ØÛÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÏÛÈÈ×ÊÉ áßõÓÆ×ÎÈÔ×ÌÛÉÉÛÕ×ÍÖÈÓÏ×ÛÎØÈÔ×ÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÈÔÛÈÔÛØ Ã×ÈÈÍÚ×Ø×È×ÊÏÓÎ×ØÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÕÊ××ØÈÔÛÈÓÈÅÛÉÓÎÈÔ×ÓÊ ÙÍÐÐ×ÙÈÓÆ×ÓÎÈ×Ê×ÉÈÈÍÖÇÊÈÔ×ÊÉÈÊ×ÛÏÐÓÎ×ÈÔ×ÐÓÈÓÕÛÈÓÍÎÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉóÎ ÙÍÎÉÓØ×ÊÓÎÕÆÛÊÓÍÇÉÍÌÈÓÍÎÉÓÈÅÛÉÛÕÊ××ØÈÍÓÎÆ×ÉÈÓÕÛÈ×ÈÔ× ÌÍÉÉÓÚÓÐÓÈÃÍÖÛØÍÌÈÓÎÕÛÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÉÓÏÓÐÛÊÈÍÈÔÛÈÇÈÓÐÓÂ×ØÚÃÈÔ× çÎÓÍÎÛÎØÈÔ×ïÓÎÓÉÈÊÃÍÖùÍÏÏÇÎÓÈÃéÛÖ×ÈÃÛÎØùÍÊÊ×ÙÈÓÍÎÛÐ é×ÊÆÓÙ×ÉÊ×ÕÛÊØÓÎÕ©ÈÊÛÎÉÓÈÓÍÎÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ɨèÔÍÉ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÅÔÓÙÔ Å×Ê×ÏÛÎÃÔÇÎØÊ×ØÓÎÎÇÏÚ×ÊÅ×Ê×ÖÓÐ×ØÛÉÈÔ×Ê×ÉÇÐÈÍÖÈÔ×ÏÛÒÍÊ Ê×ÍÊÕÛÎÓÂÛÈÓÍÎÅÓÈÔÓÎÈÔÛÈïÓÎÓÉÈÊÃõÓÆ×ÎÏÃ×ÄÌ×ÊÓ×ÎÙ×ÓÎÈÔÛÈ ÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÏÃÛÉÉÓÉÈÛÎÙ×ÅÛÉÉÍÇÕÔÈÓÎÈÔÓÉÏÛÈÈ×Ê áßûÈÍÇÊÔ×ÛÊÓÎÕÔ×ÐØÍÎòÛÎÇÛÊà  ÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÕÊ××ØÈÍÛ ÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÓÉÉÇ×ÉÓÎÙÐÇØÓÎÕ o ûÐÐÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÛÉÍÖòÛÎÇÛÊà  ÛÎØ ÈÔÍÉ×ÖÓÐ×ØÓÎÈÔ×ÖÍÊ×É××ÛÚÐ×ÖÇÈÇÊ×ÖÐÍÅÓÎÕÖÊÍÏÈÔ× ÓÎÈ×ÊÌÊ×ÈÛÈÓÍÎÛÌÌÐÓÙÛÈÓÍÎÛÎØÛØÏÓÎÓÉÈÊÛÈÓÍÎÍÖûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÖÍÊØ×È×ÊÏÓÎÛÈÓÍÎ o åÔÓÐ×ÓÈÓÉÇÎØ×ÊÉÈÍÍØÈÔÛÈÛÐÐØ×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÉÇÎØ×ÊÈÔÓÉÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉ ÅÓÐÐÚ×ÙÍÎÉÓÉÈ×ÎÈÈÔ×ÃÛÊ×ÅÓÈÔÍÇÈÌÊ×Ù×Ø×ÎÈÍÊÌÊ×ÒÇØÓÙ× ÓÎÛÙÙÍÊØÛÎÙ×ÅÓÈÔûÊÈÓÙÐ×    o óÅÓÐÐØ×È×ÊÏÓÎ×ÈÔ×ÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÈÍÚ×ÖÍÐÐÍÅ×ØÖÍÊÈÔ× ÐÓÈÓÕÛÈÓÍÎÍÖÈÔ×É×ÏÛÈÈ×ÊÉ áßèÔ×ÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÖÍÊÈÔ×ÐÓÈÓÕÛÈÓÍÎÍÖÈÔ×Ê×ÏÛÓÎÓÎÕÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÉÔÍÇÐØ Ú××ÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÈÛÎØÌÊÍÆÓØ×ÛÈÓÏ×ÐÃÛÎØÛÌÌÊÍÌÊÓÛÈ×ÖÓÎÛÐÊ×ÉÍÐÇÈÓÍÎ - 4 - óÎÛÊÊÓÆÓÎÕÛÈÏÃØ×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÓÎÈÔÓÉÊ×ÕÛÊØÙÍÎÉÓØ×ÊÛÈÓÍÎÅÛÉÕÓÆ×ÎÈÍ ûÊÈÓÙÐ×   ÅÔÓÙÔÉÈÛÈ×É èÔ×Ï×ØÓÛÈÍÊ ÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÍÊÉÔÛÐÐ×ÎØ×ÛÆÍÇÊÈÍÛÉÉÓÉÈÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×É ÈÍÉ×ÈÈÐ×ÈÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÚÃÏ×ØÓÛÈÓÍÎóÖÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÊ×ÇÎÛÚÐ× ÈÍÉ×ÈÈÐ×ÈÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÚÃÏ×ØÓÛÈÓÍÎÈÔ×Ï×ØÓÛÈÍÊ ÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÍÊ ÉÔÛÐÐØ×È×ÊÏÓÎ×ÈÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÚÃÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÓÍÎåÔ×Î Ø×È×ÊÏÓÎÓÎÕÈÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÚÃÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÓÍÎÈÔ× Ï×ØÓÛÈÍÊ ÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÍÊÏÛÃÐÓÏÓÈÈÔ×ÎÛÈÇÊ×ÛÎØ×ÄÈ×ÎÈÍÖÈÔ× ×ÆÓØ×ÎÙ×ÛÎØÏÛÃÓÏÌÍÉ×ÉÇÙÔÙÍÎØÓÈÓÍÎÉÛÉÔ×ÍÊÉÔ× ÙÍÎÉÓØ×ÊÉÛÌÌÊÍÌÊÓÛÈ×èÔ×Ï×ØÓÛÈÍÊ ÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÍÊÉÔÛÐÐÕÓÆ×Û ÉÇÙÙÓÎÙÈØ×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÅÓÈÔÓÎÖÓÆ×ØÛÃÉÛÖÈ×ÊÙÍÏÌÐ×ÈÓÎÕ ÌÊÍÙ××ØÓÎÕÉÇÎÐ×ÉÉÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÕÊ××ÍÈÔ×ÊÅÓÉ× áßûÉÅÛÉÈÔ×ÙÛÉ×ÓÎÈÔשÈÊÛÎÉÓÈÓÍΨÌÊÍÙ×ÉÉÈÔ×Ê×ÛÊ×ÛÐÛÊÕ× ÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÈÍØ×È×ÊÏÓÎ×ÛÎØÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÛÊ×ÛÕÊ××ØÈÔÛÈ ©ÈÊÛØÓÈÓÍÎÛÐÛÊÚÓÈÊÛÈÓÍΨÅÓÐÐÎÍÈÉ×ÊÆ×ÈÔ×ÓÊÌÇÊÌÍÉ×èÔ×Ê×ÖÍÊ×ÓÎ ÛÙÙÍÊØÛÎÙ×ÅÓÈÔÏÃÒÇÊÓÉØÓÙÈÓÍÎÈÍÉÍØ×È×ÊÏÓÎ×ÈÔ×É×ÏÛÈÈ×ÊÉÅÓÐÐ Ú×ÐÓÈÓÕÛÈ×ØÍÎÈÔ×ÖÍÐÐÍÅÓÎÕÚÛÉÓÉ õÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÛÊ×ÈÍÚ×ÌÊ×É×ÎÈ×ØÚÃÅÛÃÍÖ×ÛÙÔÌÛÊÈà ÌÊ×É×ÎÈÓÎÕÛÉÈÛÈ×Ï×ÎÈÍÖÈÔ×ÖÛÙÈÉÅÓÈÔÛÌÌÊÍÌÊÓÛÈ× ØÍÙÇÏ×ÎÈÉÓÖÛÎÃÛÎØÛÙÙÍÏÌÛÎÃÓÎÕÉÇÚÏÓÉÉÓÍÎÉó ÇÎØ×ÊÉÈÛÎØÈÔÛÈÓÎÏÛÎÃÙÛÉ×ÉÌÛÊÈÓÙÇÐÛÊÉÔÛÆ×Ú××Î ÌÊÍÆÓØ×ØÛÎØØÍÙÇÏ×ÎÈÉ×ÄÙÔÛÎÕ×ØèÔÛÈÌÊ×ÌÛÊÛÈÍÊà ÅÍÊÑÉÔÍÇÐØÖÇÊÈÔ×ÊÛÉÉÓÉÈ×ÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÙà óÊ×ÙÍÕÎÓÂ×ÈÔÛÈÉÍÏ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÍÊÉÛÎØÏÛÎÛÕ×ÊÓÛÐ×ÏÌÐÍÃ××É ÏÛÃÅÓÉÔÈÍÛÈÈ×ÎØÛÎØÌÊÍÆÓØ×ÍÊÛÐ×ÆÓØ×ÎÙ×ôÍÅ×Æ×Ê ÕÓÆ×ÎÈÔ×ÈÛÉÑÛÈÔÛÎØÛÎØÈÔ×ÈÓÏ×ÚÃÅÔÓÙÔÈÍØÍÓÈó ÍÊØ×ÊÍÎÐÃÈÔ×ÙÍÏÏÓÈÈ××Ï×ÏÚ×ÊÉÖÊÍÏ×ÛÙÔÌÛÊÈÃÅÓÐÐ ÛÈÈ×ÎØ óÈÏÛÃÚ×ÈÔÛÈÓÎÛÖ×ÅÓÎÉÈÛÎÙ×ÉÉÍÏ×ÙÍÎÖÇÉÓÍÎÏÓÕÔÈ ÛÊÓÉ×Ê×ÕÛÊØÓÎÕÙ×ÊÈÛÓÎÖÛÙÈÉóÈÏÓÕÔÈÛÐÉÍÔÛÌÌ×ÎÈÔÛÈó ÅÓÐÐÖÓÎØÈÔÛÈÓÎÉÇÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÈ×ÆÓØ×ÎÙ×ÔÛÉÚ××ÎÌÊÍÆÓØ×ØóÎ ÈÔÍÉ×ÓÎÉÈÛÎÙ×ÉÉÔÍÇÐØÈÔ×ÃÛÊÓÉ×óÅÓÐÐØÓÊ×ÙÈÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×É - 5 - ÈÍÉÌ×ÛÑÛÕÛÓÎÅÓÈÔÈÔ×ÓÊÌÊÓÎÙÓÌÐ×ÉÈÍÛÉÙ×ÊÈÛÓÎÈÔ×ÖÛÙÈÉ ÍÊÈÔ×ÊÛÈÓÍÎÛÐ×Ú×ÔÓÎØÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓÙÇÐÛÊÍÇÈÉÈÛÎØÓÎÕÏÛÈÈ×Ê óÎÈÔ××Æ×ÎÈóÖÓÎØÈÔ×Ê×ÓÉÉÈÓÐÐÇÎÙ×ÊÈÛÓÎÈÃÊ×ÕÛÊØÓÎÕÖÛÙÈÉ óÊ×É×ÊÆ×ÈÔ×ÊÓÕÔÈÈÍÛÉÑÖÍÊÆÓÆÛÆÍÙ××ÆÓØ×ÎÙ×óÈÓÉÏà ÔÍÌ×ÈÔÛÈÈÔÓÉÎ××ØÉÔÛÐÐÎ×Æ×ÊÛÊÓÉ× ôÍÌ×ÖÇÐÐÃØ×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÉÙÛÎÚ×ÓÉÉÇ×ØÅÓÈÔÓÎÛÊ×ÐÛÈÓÆ×ÐÃÉÔÍÊÈ Ì×ÊÓÍØÍÖÈÓÏ×ÖÍÐÐÍÅÓÎÕÉÇÚÏÓÉÉÓÍÎÉïÃØ×ÙÓÉÓÍÎÉÅÓÐÐ ÙÍÎÈÛÓÎÚÊÓ×ÖÊ×ÛÉÍÎÉÛÎØÉÇÖÖÓÙÓ×ÎÈÊÛÈÓÍÎÛÐ×ÉÍÛÉÈÍ ÌÊÍÆÓØ×ÈÔ×ÌÛÊÈÓ×ÉÅÓÈÔÛÎÓÎÈ×ÊÌÊ×ÈÛÈÓÍÎÈÔ×Ê×ÚÃÛÐÐÍÅÓÎÕ ÈÔ×ÏÈÍÏÍÆ×ÖÍÊÅÛÊØ á ßïÉðÛÇÊÛæÛÊÙÍ×ÅÛÉÓÎÓÈÓÛÐÐÃÌÐÛÙ×ØÓÎÈÔ× ÔÍÇÊÖÐ×ÄÓÚÐ×ÌÛÊÈ ÈÓÏ×ÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃóÎÈÔ×ÉÌÊÓÎÕÍÖ ÉÔ×ÖÓÐ×ØÛÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÈÔÛÈ ÛÐÐ×Õ×ØÉÔ×ÅÛÉÏÓÉÐ×ØÚéÐÍÙÛÐÏÛÎÛÕ×Ï×ÎȨÅÔÓÙÔÙÛÇÉ×ØÔ×ÊÈÍ ×Ð×ÙÈÈÔ× ÔÍÇÊÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃÍÖÅÍÊÑÊÛÈÔ×ÊÈÔÛÎ  ÔÍÇÊÉéÔ× ÙÍÎÈ×ÎØ×ØÈÔÛÈÛÉÛÊ×ÉÇÐÈÍÖÈÔÓÉ©ÏÓÉÊ×ÌÊ×É×ÎÈÛÈÓÍΨÉÔ×ÔÛÉ ÉÇÖÖ×Ê×Ø©ÕÊ×ÛÈÖÓÎÛÎÙÓÛÐÐÍÉÉÛÎØÔÛÊØÉÔǪ́íÎÈÔ×ÖÛÙ×ÍÖÈÔ× ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÉÔ×ÇÊÕ×ØÈÔÛÈÈÔ×÷ÏÌÐÍÃ×ÊÔÛÉ©ÇÎØ×ÊÈÛÑ×ÎÈÍÔÓÊ× ÎÇÏ×ÊÍÇÉÛØØÓÈÓÍÎÛÐ ÔÍÇÊÙÍÇÊÈÊ×ÕÓÉÈÊÛÊÉÛÉÅ×ÐÐÛÉ ÇÎÙÐÛÉÉÓÖÓ×ØÙÍÎÈÊÛÙÈÊ×ÕÓÉÈÊÛÊÉÛÎØÔÛÆ×ÓÎØÓÙÛÈ×ØÈÔÛÈ×Æ×ÊÃ×ÖÖÍÊÈ ÅÓÐÐÚ×ÏÛØ×ÈÍÙÇÈÏÃÔÍÇÊÉÚÛÙÑÈÍÈÔ×ÏÓÎÓÏÇÏÊ×ËÇÓÊ×Ï×ÎÈÍÖ ÔÍÇÊɨúÃÅÛÃÍÖÊ×Ï×ØÃÉÔ×ÉÍÇÕÔÈÙÍÏÌ×ÎÉÛÈÓÍÎÍÊÈÔ× ÍÌÌÍÊÈÇÎÓÈÃÈÍ©Ê×É×Ð×ÙȨÈÔ×ÔÍÇÊÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃÉÔ×ÅÓÉÔ×ÉÈÍÅÍÊÑ á ßèÔ×Ê×ÅÛÉÎÍ×ÆÓØ×ÎÙ×ÌÊÍÆÓØ×ØÈÔÛÈÅÍÇÐØÐ×ÛØÏ×ÈÍÖÓÎØÖÍÊÈÔ× ÕÊÓ×ÆÍÊïÉæÛÊÙÍ×ÐÓÑ×ÍÈÔ×ÊöìèÉÈÛÖÖÔÛØÛÎÍÌÌÍÊÈÇÎÓÈÃÈÍ ×Ð×ÙÈÈÔ×ÏÓÎÓÏÇÏÔÍÇÊÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃÉÔ×ÅÛÎÈ×ØéÔ×ÙÔÍÉ×ÈÍÚ× ÛÉÉÓÕÎ×ØÛÏÓÎÓÏÇÏÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖ ÔÍÇÊÉÛÎØÈÔ×÷ÏÌÐÍÃ×ÊÓÉ ÎÍÈÍÚÐÓÕ×ØÈÍÌÊÍÆÓØ×ÏÍÊ×óÈÅÍÇÐØÛÌÌ×ÛÊÈÔÛÈÈÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÍÊ ÈÔÍÇÕÔÈÉÔ×ÙÍÇÐØÅÍÊÑÈÔ×ÉÛÏ×ÎÇÏÚ×ÊÍÖÔÍÇÊÉÛÉÉÔ×ÔÛØÌÊÓÍÊ ÈÍÔ×ÊÙÔÛÎÕ×ÍÖÙÛÈ×ÕÍÊÃÅÔÓÙÔÅÍÇÐØÊ×ÉÇÐÈÓÎÍÆ×ÊÈÓÏ×ÌÛÃÖÍÊ ÏÍÊ×ÔÍÇÊÉèÔÓÉØÓØÎÍÈÍÙÙÇÊ - 6 - á èÔ×÷ÏÌÐÍÃ×ÊÉÈÛÈ×ØÈÔÛÈÓÈØÓØÔÓÊ×ÉÍÏ×ÛØØÓÈÓÍÎÛÐÉÈÛÖÖÉÍÛÉÈÍ ÏÓÎÓÏÓÂ×ÈÔ×ÛÏÍÇÎÈÍÖÍÆ×ÊÈÓÏ×ÓÈÏÇÉÈÌÛÃÍÇÈóÈÓÉ×ÎÈÓÈÐ×ØÈÍ ØÍÉÍÓÎÛÙÙÍÊØÛÎÙ×ÅÓÈÔÓÈÉÏÛÎÛÕ×Ï×ÎȪÉÊÓÕÔÈÉóÈÓÉÎÍÈÛ ÆÓÍÐÛÈÓÍÎÍÖûÌÌ×ÎØÓÄ ÈÍØÍÉÍ á ßèÔ×ÕÊÓ×ÆÛÎÙ×ÓÉØ×ÎÓ×Ø øÛÈ×ØÛÈèÍÊÍÎÈÍÈÔÓÉØÛÃÍÖûÌÊÓÐ  ÈÔ ö×ÐÓÙÓÈÃøúÊÓÕÕÉæÓÙ×ùÔÛÓÊ